The Top Ranked Starting Pitchers of the 1910's

 

AinsworthSports.com

 


Home

 

Updates

 

Sports

 

Upcoming/Recent Events

 

Polls

 

Contact Us

 

Links

 


Other Links > Baseball > Player Rankings by Position

 

The Top Ranked Starting Pitchers of the 1910's

 

Notes:

The ratings on this page comes from AinsworthSports.com's own rating system.  The lower the rating the better.

Players had to complete at least one qualifying season to be included in this list.

A qualifying year is any year that a player pitched 120 innings and a majority of the games he pitched in were starts.

Player's ratings are penalized for every year under 5 qualifying years.

 

Rnk   Player Rating
1   Walter Johnson 1.45750
2   Pete Alexander 2.28900
3   Christy Mathewson 11.70400
4   Hippo Vaughn 12.62089
5   Ed Walsh 16.19467
6   Rube Marquard 16.54338
7   Eddie Plank 23.18586
8   Harry Coveleski 25.62133
9   Eddie Cicotte 25.99144
10   Larry Cheney 26.07143
11   Smoky Joe Wood 26.74500
12   Stan Coveleski 26.84600
13   Babe Adams 27.04657
14   Hooks Dauss 27.32129
15   Carl Mays 27.45200
16   Slim Sallee 28.22822
17   Jeff Tesreau 29.05417
18   Jim Bagby 29.27000
19   Dutch Leonard 31.54386
20   Chief Bender 33.71400
21   Dick Rudolph 35.03500
22   Jeff Pfeffer 35.77420
23   Wilbur Cooper 37.16967
24   Lefty Tyler 38.43550
25   Jack Coombs 40.50183
26   Fred Toney 40.58180
27   Mordecai Brown 40.60500
28   Babe Ruth 42.19780
29   Red Faber 45.98550
30   Rube Benton 46.14029
31   Jim Scott 46.35200
32   Ray Collins 46.46000
33   Al Mamaux 46.89867
34   Russ Ford 48.13175
35   Pol Perritt 48.38017
36   Nap Rucker 50.76260
37   Allan Sothoron 51.34267
38   Hod Eller 51.41200
39   Vean Gregg 51.42920
40   Claude Hendrix 51.49250
41   Lefty Williams 52.08333
42   King Cole 54.03800
43   Bob Groom 54.08033
44   Jim Shaw 55.02480
45   Tom Seaton 55.19950
46   Bernie Boland 56.12333
47   Bob Shawkey 56.13580
48   Bill Doak 56.58817
49   Ray Caldwell 58.03189
50   Red Ames 58.09588
51   Art Nehf 58.35800
52   Carl Weilman 59.16580
53   Cy Morgan 59.79500
54   George Mullin 60.50000
55   Howie Camnitz 60.83250
56   Hugh Bedient 61.41100
57   George Suggs 61.48900
58   Erskine Mayer 62.76140
59   Eppa Rixey 63.22917
60   Ferdie Schupp 65.15000
61   Earl Moore 65.38167
62   Ernie Shore 66.03400
63   Ed Willett 66.08450
64   Bob Harmon 66.93929
65   Cy Falkenberg 67.47100
66   Jack Quinn 67.62250
67   Guy Morton 68.36617
68   Bullet Joe Bush 69.08400
69   Dutch Ruether 69.19000
70   Willie Mitchell 69.56250
71   Jean Dubuc 71.41225
72   Ray Fisher 71.52514
73   Joe Benz 74.18017
74   Bill James 74.38388
75   Lefty Leifield 75.14700
76   Al Demaree 75.43786
77   Tom Hughes 75.65425
78   Rube Foster 78.38125
79   Phil Douglas 78.53760
80   Reb Russell 78.63860
81   Jesse Barnes 79.01667
82   Joe Boehling 80.98200
83   Buck O'Brien 81.31000
84   Jimmy Lavender 82.69983
85   Bert Gallia 82.92100
86   Burleigh Grimes 83.02500
87   Lew Richie 83.32800
88   Leon Cadore 83.53000
89   Harry Gaspar 83.78250
90   Ed Reulbach 84.03200
91   Harry Harper 84.16350
92   Hooks Wiltse 84.97567
93   Frank Lange 85.17767
94   Fred Blanding 85.31233
95   Art Fromme 85.41333
96   Sherry Smith 86.13300
97   Bill Donovan 86.66100
98   Lee Meadows 86.73880
99   Earl Hamilton 87.47343
100   Pete Schneider 87.89020
101   Pat Ragan 89.18033
102   Gene Dale 89.18800
103   Herb Pennock 90.39800
104   Doc White 91.13667
105   Frank Miller 91.99100
106   Dave Davenport 92.39500
107   Sad Sam Jones 93.12500
108   Bob Ewing 93.22800
109   George McQuillan 93.50600
110   Louis Drucke 95.14700
111   Ad Brennan 97.31650
112   Hub Perdue 100.07100
113   Bert Humphries 100.09625
114   Joe Lake 100.24775
115   George Pierce 100.69800
116   Howard Ehmke 101.71000
117   Orval Overall 102.82300
118   Charley Hall 103.53000
119   Doc Ayers 103.73000
120   Slim Love 104.33800
121   Jack Warhop 104.43400
122   Bobby Keefe 104.74200
123   Boardwalk Brown 105.98367
124   Scott Perry 106.35600
125   Fritz Coumbe 106.56000
126   Gene Krapp 110.49900
127   Sam Frock 110.49900
128   Ed Summers 111.60800
129   Red Causey 112.82000
130   George Kahler 113.83000
131   Bill Steele 113.98150
132   George Chalmers 114.18350
133   Cy Barger 114.48650
134   Mike Prendergast 115.44800
135   Harry Krause 116.25600
136   Jack Rowan 116.25600
137   Urban Shocker 116.86000
138   Ed Klepfer 117.67000
139   Hank Thormahlen 117.67000
140   Elmer Myers 118.74333
141   Joe Oeschger 119.38500
142   Brad Hogg 120.69800
143   Jimmy Ring 120.90000
144   Harry McIntire 121.20300
145   Marty O'Toole 121.45550
146   Elmer Jacobs 123.45250
147   Gene Packard 123.52400
148   Chief Johnson 123.93200
149   George Mogridge 124.13000
150   Wheezer Dell 126.10150
151   George Baumgardner 126.45500
152   Jack Powell 126.82333
153   Al Mattern 126.96000
154   Marv Goodwin 127.77000
155   Ray Keating 128.67500
156   Charlie Smith 129.83850
157   Cliff Curtis 131.35575
158   Elmer Steele 131.60800
159   Grover Lowdermilk 131.60800
160   Roy Mitchell 131.60800
161   Nick Cullop 132.01000
162   Bill Steen 132.44567
163   Johnny Lush 133.52700
164   George McConnell 137.15900
165   Fred Beebe 137.36500
166   Larry Pape 137.36500
167   Hank Robinson 137.56500
168   Allen Russell 137.96900
169   Raleigh Aitchison 137.97100
170   Weldon Wyckoff 138.12050
171   Buster Brown 138.13533
172   Dixie Walker 138.47400
173   Earl Yingling 139.07800
174   Hal Carlson 139.08000
175   Fred Olmstead 139.28400
176   Elmer Knetzer 140.39300
177   Lew Moren 141.20300
178   Ed Karger 141.35250
179   Frank Shellenback 142.11200
180   Jing Johnson 144.13000
181   Marc Hall 145.04100
182   Sailor Stroud 146.20050
183   Doc Scanlan 146.96000
184   Ralph Works 147.71550
185   Bill Burns 148.06900
186   Frank Smith 148.06900
187   Carl Cashion 149.99000
188   Earl Moseley 150.79800
189   Ed Lafitte 150.79800
190   George Bell 150.79800
191   Cy Young 150.94750
192   Ernie Koob 152.01000
193   Clarence Mitchell 153.22000
194   Doc Reisling 154.63600
195   Ben Tincup 154.93900
196   Win Noyes 156.05000
197   Otto Hess 156.50250
198   Spec Harkness 156.55500
199   Rube Bressler 157.46200
200   Roy Sanders 157.66600
201   Al Schulz 157.71450
202   Kirby White 158.47400
203   Barney Pelty 159.58300
204   Mike Regan 160.09000
205   Rip Hagerman 160.39100
206   Joe Engel 160.39300
207   George Smith 160.99700
208   Dolly Gray 161.50200
209   Fred Anderson 162.11000
210   Frank Allen 163.06750
211   Tom Rogers 163.92600
212   Byron Houck 164.13000
213   Frank Woodward 164.13000
214   Vic Willis 164.23100
215   Walt Leverenz 166.15000
216   Bob Steele 166.35000
217   Dana Fillingim 168.17000
218   Erv Kantlehner 169.53150
219   Jakie May 169.98600
220   Eric Erickson 170.19000
221   Walt Dickson 173.82400
222   Bill Schardt 175.74500
223   Rollie Naylor 178.27000
224   Eddie Stack 180.29000
225   Irv Young 181.50200
226   Rudy Kallio 182.10800
227   Frank Corridon 183.42100
228   Fred Link 185.34000
229   George Cunningham 186.55200
230   Marty McHale 186.75400
231   George Dumont 188.37000
232   Mack Allison 188.37000
233   Mellie Wolfgang 188.37000
234   Cecil Ferguson 189.17800
235   Roy Golden 189.17800
236   Rube Schauer 190.39000
237   Bunny Hearn 190.99600
238   Orlie Weaver 191.09700
239   Bill Bailey 193.01600
240   Dan Griner 193.01600
241   Mule Watson 193.21800
242   Farmer Ray 194.93500
243   Rube Marshall 195.23800
244   Joe Willis 196.45000
245   Roy Walker 197.35900
246   Jack Nabors 198.47000
247   Happy Finneran 199.88400

 


[Home]  [Updates]  [Sports]  [Upcoming/Recent Events]  [Polls]  [Contact Us]  [Links]  [Our Facebook Page]  [Our Twitter Page]