The Top Ranked Football Players of All-Time from New York High Schools Help Keep the Site Ad Free By Supporting us at Patreon
AinsworthSports.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Top Ranked Football Players of All-Time from New York High Schools
Notes: This is a list of the greatest pro players who finished high school in this state.
What players did in high school or college does not factor into this list.
| High School | Athlete | POS | Rookie | Rnk |
| Adams (Queens) | Don Gault | QB | 1970 | 21004 |
| Adams (Queens) | Michael Fladell | OL | 2008 | 31714 |
| Albany (Albany) | Charlie Leigh | RB | 1965 | 8338 |
| Albany (Albany) | Charlie Leigh (PR) | PR | 1965 | 11355 |
| Albany (Albany) | Charlie Leigh (KR) | KR | 1965 | 14885 |
| Albion (Albion) | Tom Colella | RB | 1942 | 3119 |
| Albion (Albion) | Tom Colella (P) | P | 1942 | 6723 |
| Albion (Albion) | Tom Colella (KR) | KR | 1942 | 12569 |
| All Hallows (Bronx) | Jim White | OL | 1946 | 5018 |
| Allegany (Allegany) | Bill Kellogg | RB | 1924 | 11757 |
| Amsterdam (Amsterdam) | Josh Beekman | OL | 2007 | 22322 |
| Aquinas Institute (Rochester) | Jamir Jones | LB | 2020 | 27682 |
| Aquinas Institute (Rochester) | Jarron Jones | OL | 2017 | 28400 |
| Aquinas Institute (Rochester) | Earnest Edwards | WR | 2021 | 35796 |
| Archbishop Molloy (Jamaica) | Jim M. LeClair | QB | 1966 | 14926 |
| Archbishop Stepinac (White Plains) | Bob Hyland | OL | 1967 | 7234 |
| Archbishop Stepinac (White Plains) | Eric Ogbogu | DL | 1998 | 14193 |
| Archbishop Stepinac (White Plains) | Malcolm Koonce | DL | 2021 | 18997 |
| Arlington (Lagrangeville) | Dwayne Gordon | LB | 1993 | 7553 |
| Arlington (Lagrangeville) | Bill T. Johnson | RB | 1985 | 8334 |
| Arlington (Lagrangeville) | Ken Sawyer | DB | 1974 | 25894 |
| Arlington (Lagrangeville) | Larry Riley | DB | 1977 | 28658 |
| Athena (Greece) | Mark Walczak | TE | 1986 | 39673 |
| Atmar-Parish-Williamstown (Parish) | Mike Bernard | OL | 1991 | 31481 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Harlan Carr | RB | 1927 | 11902 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Buddy Hardeman (PR) | PR | 1978 | 13946 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Buddy Hardeman | RB | 1978 | 14552 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Buddy Hardeman (KR) | KR | 1978 | 15566 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | John Bove | DL | 1951 | 35688 |
| August Martin (Queens) | Tutan Reyes | OL | 2000 | 17805 |
| Baker (Baldwinsville) | Jason Boltus | QB | 2009 | 23142 |
| Baldwin (Baldwin) | Brandon T. Moore | LB | 2002 | 8248 |
| Baldwin (Baldwin) | Bob Reifsnyder | DL | 1960 | 9112 |
| Baldwin (Baldwin) | Paul Nosworthy | OL | 2020 | 38855 |
| Batavia (Batavia) | Don Bosseler | RB | 1957 | 1595 |
| Batavia (Batavia) | Eddie Allen | RB | 1947 | 24817 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Ronnie Harmon | RB | 1986 | 1553 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Bobby Hammond | RB | 1976 | 9627 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Bobby Hammond (PR) | PR | 1976 | 9903 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Bobby Hammond (KR) | KR | 1976 | 12204 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Ronnie Harmon (KR) | KR | 1986 | 12238 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Derrick Harmon | RB | 1984 | 13177 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Derrick Harmon (KR) | KR | 1984 | 16109 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Bill Erickson | OL | 1948 | 16390 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Kevin Harmon | RB | 1988 | 23251 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Cecil Doggette | DB | 1992 | 26987 |
| Bayside (Queens) | Aslam Sterling | OL | 2013 | 36005 |
| Beach Channel (Rockaway ParK) | Folorunso Fatukasi | DL | 2018 | 10472 |
| Bennett (Buffalo) | Isaiah McDuffie | LB | 2021 | 13906 |
| Bergtraum (New York) | Dennis Bligen | RB | 1984 | 20354 |
| Bethpage (Bethpage) | Dennis Macholz | TE | 1973 | 37014 |
| Binghamton (Binghamton) | Bob Gillson | OL | 1930 | 8195 |
| Binghamton (Binghamton) | Joel Davis | OL | 1996 | 31426 |
| Bishop Duffy (Niagara Falls) | Charley Leo | OL | 1960 | 9794 |
| Bishop Duffy (Niagara Falls) | Jim Leo | DL | 1960 | 18811 |
| Bishop Gibbons (North Tonawanda) | Ed Harmon | LB | 1968 | 21012 |
| Bishop Kearney (Irondequoit) | Nathan Carter | RB | 2025 | 19919 |
| Bishop Kearney (Irondequoit) | Rene Ingoglia | RB | 1996 | 30541 |
| Bishop Kearney (Irondequoit) | Quentin Gause | LB | 2016 | 37157 |
| Bishop Ludden (Syracuse) | Wendall Williams | WR | 2016 | 37028 |
| Bishop Timon (Buffalo) | Demone Harris | DL | 2018 | 28389 |
| Bishop Timon-St. Jude (Buffalo) | Sean Doctor | RB | 1991 | 33031 |
| Blodgett (Syracuse) | Bing Miller | OL | 1929 | 7315 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Ed Kolman | OL | 1940 | 5039 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Revie Sorey | OL | 1975 | 5134 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Jim Ricca | DL | 1951 | 5215 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Allie Sherman | QB | 1943 | 7569 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Alex Wizbicki | DB | 1947 | 11151 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Izzy Yablock | RB | 1930 | 11923 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Hal McCullough | QB | 1941 | 13196 |
| Brentwood (Brentwood) | Gary L. Brown | OL | 1994 | 20799 |
| Brighton (Brighton) | Bob Briggs | RB | 1967 | 20169 |
| Bronxville (Bronxville) | Jeff White | K | 1973 | 15706 |
| Brooklyn Prep (Brooklyn) | John Dockery | DB | 1966 | 12895 |
| Brooklyn Prep (Brooklyn) | Si Titus | OL | 1940 | 13882 |
| Brooklyn Prep (Brooklyn) | George Titus | OL | 1944 | 20535 |
| Burgard (Buffalo) | Al Dekdebrun | QB | 1946 | 8867 |
| Burnt Hills (Burnt Hills) | Eric Torkelson | RB | 1974 | 6159 |
| Caledonia (Caledonia) | Steamer Horning | OL | 1920 | 5155 |
| Calhoun (Merrick) | Steve Hammond | LB | 1983 | 15906 |
| Campus Magnet (Queens) | Blessuan Austin | DB | 2019 | 28483 |
| Canandaigua Academy (Canandaigua) | Scott Greene | RB | 1996 | 14561 |
| Canandaigua Academy (Canandaigua) | Troy Stark | OL | 1996 | 37758 |
| Canarise (Brooklyn) | Lance Schulters | DB | 1998 | 2548 |
| Canarsie (Brooklyn) | Leon Williams | LB | 2006 | 14587 |
| Canarsie (Brooklyn) | Jermaine Miles | DL | 1997 | 21934 |
| Canarsie (Brooklyn) | Michael Titley | TE | 1991 | 24935 |
| Canarsie (Brooklyn) | Mel Parker | DL | 1973 | 31590 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Phil McConkey (PR) | PR | 1979 | 4826 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Phil McConkey | WR | 1979 | 7536 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Phil McConkey (KR) | KR | 1979 | 13490 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Sam Cordovano | OL | 1930 | 16781 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Qadree Ollison | RB | 2019 | 18282 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | John Urschel | OL | 2014 | 24930 |
| Canisius (Buffalo) | Mercer Timmis | RB | 2016 | 27790 |
| Canton (Canton) | Shag Sheard | RB | 1923 | 10985 |
| Cardinal Hayes (Bronx) | Willie Colon | OL | 2006 | 5818 |
| Cardinal Hayes (Bronx) | Stalin Colinet | DL | 1997 | 14827 |
| Cardinal Hayes (Bronx) | Steve Colavito | LB | 1974 | 29463 |
| Cardinal Mooney (Rochester) | Jeff Weston | OL | 1979 | 24672 |
| Cardinal O'Hara (Tonawanda) | Jeff Yeates | DL | 1974 | 3926 |
| Cardinal Spellman (Bronx) | Chris Manhertz | TE | 2015 | 11662 |
| Carey (Franklin Square) | Carl Capria | DB | 1974 | 25893 |
| Carey (Franklin Square) | Anthony Corvino | OL | 1987 | 39150 |
| Carle Place (Carle Place) | Matt Snell | RB | 1964 | 3295 |
| Cathedral (Rochester) | Hal Clark | E | 1920 | 10957 |
| Cathedral (Rochester) | Red Quigley | RB | 1920 | 13290 |
| Cazenovia (Cazenovia) | Steve Suhey | OL | 1948 | 11563 |
| Cazenovia (Cazenovia) | Joe Willson | OL | 1926 | 19587 |
| Central (Bolivar) | Bob Torrey | RB | 1979 | 25285 |
| Central (Colonie) | David Gamble | WR | 1994 | 35113 |
| Central (Endicott) | Joe Mott | LB | 1989 | 19100 |
| Central (Goshen) | Dale Memmelaar | OL | 1959 | 6138 |
| Central (Massena) | John Bayley | OL | 1927 | 17492 |
| Central (Onondaga) | Latavius Murray | RB | 2013 | 1477 |
| Central (Onondaga) | Latavius Murray (KR) | KR | 2013 | 14859 |
| Central (Syracuse) | Doc Alexander | OL | 1921 | 8747 |
| Central (Syracuse) | Harvey Levy | OL | 1928 | 9708 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Dick Poillon (K) | K | 1942 | 5612 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Dick Poillon | RB | 1942 | 9277 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Dick Poillon (P) | P | 1942 | 9543 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Phil LaPorta | OL | 1974 | 25116 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Victor Ochi | LB | 2016 | 39451 |
| Central (Whitesboro) | Ilia Jarostchuk | LB | 1987 | 23367 |
| Central (Wyoming) | Henry Lawrence | OL | 1974 | 1423 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | John Tice | TE | 1983 | 3428 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Roy Barker | DL | 1992 | 3925 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Mike Tice | TE | 1981 | 4722 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Clarence Jones | OL | 1991 | 6794 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Richard Tharpe | DL | 1983 | 21528 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Marlon Forbes | DB | 1996 | 23137 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Andrew Tiller | OL | 2012 | 25175 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Eric Unverzagt | LB | 1996 | 27744 |
| Central Islip (Central Islip) | Joe Moreino | DL | 1978 | 34802 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Larry Eisenhauer | DL | 1961 | 1517 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Greg Van Roten | OL | 2012 | 6759 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | John Paul Foschi | TE | 2005 | 15670 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Sean Clancy | LB | 1978 | 26619 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Mike Catapano | DL | 2013 | 26649 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Tom Claro | OL | 1996 | 28828 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | John Rogan | QB | 1982 | 35953 |
| Chatham (Chatham) | Josh Keyes | LB | 2015 | 33961 |
| Christ the King (Middle Village) | Will Poole | DB | 2004 | 25521 |
| Christ the King (Middle Village) | Maurice Evans | DL | 2009 | 33701 |
| Christ the King (Middle Village) | Will Poole (PR) | PR | 2004 | 37295 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (Albany) | Joe Vellano | DL | 2013 | 24165 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (Albany) | David Byrd | DB | 2002 | 37421 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (DeWitt) | Riley Dixon | P | 2016 | 3508 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (DeWitt) | Billy Owens | DB | 1988 | 23809 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (DeWitt) | Stevie Scott | RB | 2021 | 29594 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (Syracuse) | Marty Domres | QB | 1969 | 4343 |
| Christian Brothers Academy (Syracuse) | Walt Patulski | DL | 1972 | 6703 |
| Cicero-North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Maury Youmans | DL | 1959 | 7492 |
| Cicero-North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Curtis Johnson (DL) | DL | 2008 | 29730 |
| City Honors (Buffalo) | Ray Wagner | E | 1929 | 15194 |
| City Honors (Buffalo) | Walt Koppisch | RB | 1925 | 16657 |
| City Honors (Buffalo) | Herb Dieter | OL | 1922 | 17139 |
| Clarence (Clarence) | Gary Bugenhagen | OL | 1967 | 22537 |
| Clarence Central (Williamsville) | Mark H. Murphy | DB | 1977 | 2949 |
| Clarkston (Clarkston) | Jeff Steinberger | DL | 1968 | 31625 |
| Clarkstown (New City) | Keith Bulluck | LB | 2000 | 842 |
| Clarkstown North (New City) | Prince Emili | DL | 2022 | 35521 |
| Clarkstown South (West Nyack) | Karl Ballard | LB | 1996 | 28625 |
| Clason Point Military Academy (Bronx) | George Vergara | E | 1925 | 12436 |
| Cleveland (Buffalo) | Steven Means | DL | 2013 | 19222 |
| Cleveland Hill (Cheektowaga) | Antwon Burton | DL | 2006 | 28354 |
| Colonie (Colonie) | Chad Dukes | RB | 1995 | 23974 |
| Columbia (East Greenbush) | Rich Romer | LB | 1988 | 30550 |
| Commercial (Brooklyn) | Paul Jappe | E | 1925 | 7687 |
| Cook Academy (Montour Falls) | Stu Smith | RB | 1937 | 8474 |
| Cook Academy (Montour Falls) | Red Seick | OL | 1942 | 20412 |
| Corcoran (Syracuse) | Will D. Allen | DB | 2001 | 4331 |
| Corcoran (Syracuse) | Jo-Lonn Dunbar | LB | 2008 | 7016 |
| Corcoran (Syracuse) | Jamel Richardson | WR | 2003 | 18926 |
| Corning Free Academy (Corning) | Bob Argus | RB | 1920 | 6747 |
| Corning Free Academy (Corning) | Diddie Willson | OL | 1933 | 8403 |
| Cortland (Cortland) | Gary Wood | QB | 1964 | 6090 |
| Cortland (Cortland) | Jack Call | RB | 1957 | 10953 |
| Cortland (Cortland) | Jack Call (KR) | KR | 1957 | 12961 |
| Cortland (Cortland) | John Nichols (DB) | DB | 1963 | 36309 |
| Country Day School (Riverdale) | Calvin Hill | RB | 1969 | 629 |
| Cuba-Rushford (Cuba) | Bruce Doyle | OL | 2014 | 38538 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Vernon Turner (KR) | KR | 1990 | 7656 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Vernon Turner | RB | 1990 | 8076 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Vernon Turner (PR) | PR | 1990 | 9104 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Steve Gregory | DB | 2006 | 10085 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | James Jenkins | TE | 1991 | 11486 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Dino Mangiero | DL | 1980 | 13577 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Dominique Easley | DL | 2014 | 22204 |
| Deerfield Academy (Rochester) | Willie Roberts | DB | 1972 | 36707 |
| Delaware Academy (Delhi) | Jeff Oliver | OL | 1988 | 28683 |
| Depew (Depew) | John Kling | OL | 2016 | 35669 |
| DeSales (Lockport) | Bernard Buzyniski | LB | 1960 | 10601 |
| DeSales Catholic (Lockport) | Sean Kugler | OL | 1989 | 31511 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Sam Garnes | DB | 1997 | 4861 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Jim Germany | RB | 1975 | 17890 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Ramon Guzman | LB | 2007 | 23703 |
| Dunkirk (Dunkirk) | Bill Brace | OL | 1920 | 7095 |
| Dunkirk (Dunkirk) | Dave Graf | LB | 1975 | 12510 |
| East (Buffalo) | Bill Piccolo | OL | 1943 | 13267 |
| East (Rochester) | Roland Williams | TE | 1998 | 4575 |
| East (Rochester) | Babe Clark | RB | 1920 | 13843 |
| East (Rochester) | Tony Jordan | RB | 1988 | 17093 |
| East (Rochester) | Joe Bock | OL | 1981 | 19255 |
| East (Rochester) | Seven McGee (KR) | KR | 2025 | 35545 |
| East (Rochester) | Seven McGee (PR) | PR | 2025 | 35546 |
| East (Rochester) | Terry Grooms | OL | 1997 | 38324 |
| East (West Seneca) | Kevin Mason | QB | 1995 | 24006 |
| East (West Senecea) | Shaun Dolac | LB | 2025 | 26531 |
| East Islip (East Islip) | Frank Bianchini | WR | 1983 | 30603 |
| East Islip (Islip Terrace) | Boomer Esiason | QB | 1984 | 199 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Rich Mauti (KR) | KR | 1977 | 7247 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Rich Mauti | WR | 1977 | 7448 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Rich Mauti (PR) | PR | 1977 | 9639 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Sandro Vitiello | K | 1980 | 16155 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Rich Ohrnberger | OL | 2009 | 25650 |
| East Rockaway (East Rockaway) | Pat Ragusa | K | 1987 | 20985 |
| Eastchester (Eastchester) | Wash Serini | OL | 1948 | 8445 |
| Eastchester (Eastchester) | Eric Naposki | LB | 1988 | 24742 |
| Eastport-South Manor (Manorville) | Matt Goncalves | OL | 2024 | 17680 |
| Eden (Eden) | Bert Weidner | OL | 1989 | 13207 |
| Eisenhower (Utica) | John DiGiorgio | LB | 2006 | 20677 |
| Elwood-John Glenn (Elwood) | Ifeanyi Momah | TE | 2012 | 26701 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Sid Luckman | QB | 1939 | 189 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Sid Luckman (P) | P | 1939 | 2430 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Curtis Samuel | WR | 2017 | 3867 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Shawn Lee | DL | 1988 | 4349 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Joe Watt (PR) | PR | 1947 | 12974 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Curtis Samuel (KR) | KR | 2017 | 13163 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Joe Watt (KR) | KR | 1947 | 14370 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Ben Raimondi | QB | 1947 | 14657 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Dave Skudin | OL | 1929 | 14786 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Joe Watt | RB | 1947 | 17811 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Jack Lord | OL | 1929 | 18650 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Christian Izien | DB | 2023 | 20212 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Bob Morris | OL | 1926 | 20416 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Al Leith | RB | 1926 | 21834 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Waddy MacPhee | RB | 1926 | 22723 |
| Evander Childs (New York) | Paul Governali | QB | 1946 | 6942 |
| Fairport (Fairport) | Frank Bucher | E | 1925 | 11195 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Ron R. Heller | OL | 1984 | 4040 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Paul Lankford | DB | 1982 | 6375 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Canute Curtis | LB | 1997 | 13918 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Tom Kennedy (KR) | KR | 2019 | 18627 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Tom Kennedy (WR) | WR | 2019 | 22489 |
| Fayetteville-Manlius (Manlius) | Bob Kuziel | OL | 1972 | 9591 |
| Fayetteville-Manlius (Manlius) | Damien Rhodes | RB | 2007 | 30838 |
| Flushing (Jamaica) | Art Harms | OL | 1925 | 17062 |
| Flushing (Queens) | Jay Bromley | DL | 2014 | 21343 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Marty Beck | RB | 1921 | 13286 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Matt Brennan | RB | 1925 | 13512 |
| Fort Edward (Fort Edward) | Ed McGee | OL | 1940 | 10268 |
| Fort Hamilton (Brooklyn) | Jaiquawn Jarrett | DB | 2011 | 24470 |
| Franklin Academy (Malone) | Doug Daigneault | DB | 1960 | 22482 |
| Franklin Academy (Malone) | Doug Daigneault (KR) | KR | 1960 | 35403 |
| Free Academy (Rome) | John Dominic | DL | 1988 | 30731 |
| Free Academy (Rome) | Dana Carpenter | LB | 1974 | 30878 |
| Freeport (Freeport) | D'Brickashaw Ferguson | OL | 2006 | 1468 |
| Freeport (Freeport) | Morlon Greenwood | LB | 2001 | 3504 |
| Freeport (Freeport) | Clifton Smith (LB) | LB | 2003 | 29088 |
| Freeport (Freeport) | Jah'Sheem Martin | DL | 2019 | 38396 |
| Frewsburg (Frewsburg) | Shane Conlan | LB | 1987 | 1127 |
| Friends Academy (Locust Valley) | Rey Williams | LB | 2004 | 22857 |
| Frontier (Hamburg) | Dave Wohlabaugh | OL | 1995 | 4590 |
| Frontier (Hamburg) | Jake Schum | P | 2014 | 20863 |
| Fulton (Fulton) | John Naioti | RB | 1942 | 16528 |
| Garden City (Garden City) | Dave Jennings | P | 1974 | 1628 |
| Garden City (Garden City) | Don McCauley | RB | 1971 | 2201 |
| Garden City (Garden City) | Frank Quayle | RB | 1969 | 16999 |
| Gates-Chili (Gates) | Ernest Jackson | WR | 2009 | 21756 |
| Genesee Wesleyan Seminary (Lima) | Art Webb | OL | 1920 | 10882 |
| Geneva (Geneva) | Jasper Collins | WR | 2013 | 30822 |
| Glen Cove (Glen Cove) | Carl Karilivacz | DB | 1953 | 2439 |
| Glen Cove (Glen Cove) | Joe Rizzo | LB | 1974 | 7442 |
| Glen Cove (Glen Cove) | Ed Kasky | OL | 1942 | 15334 |
| Glen Head (Glen Head) | Hank Bjorklund | RB | 1972 | 16554 |
| Gloversville (Gloversville) | Dave Smukler | QB | 1936 | 5790 |
| Gloversville (Gloversville) | Jim Byrne | DL | 1984 | 13855 |
| Gloversville (Gloversville) | Don Wemple | E | 1941 | 16529 |
| Gloversville (Gloversville) | Ted Cirillo | OL | 1983 | 23354 |
| Gouverneur (Gouveneur) | Brian Leonard | RB | 2007 | 5752 |
| Grand Island (Grand Island) | Brett Kern | P | 2008 | 1772 |
| Grand Street (Brooklyn) | Olakunle Fatukasi | LB | 2022 | 34056 |
| Great Neck (Great Neck) | Quinn Early | WR | 1988 | 2049 |
| Greeley (Chappaqua) | Tom Gilburg (P) | P | 1961 | 6241 |
| Greeley (Chappaqua) | Rich Erenberg | RB | 1984 | 8752 |
| Greeley (Chappaqua) | Rich Erenberg (KR) | KR | 1984 | 12505 |
| Greeley (Chappaqua) | Tom Gilburg | OL | 1961 | 12731 |
| Hackley School (Tarrytown) | Jim Reilly | OL | 1970 | 19590 |
| Half Hollow Hills Central (Dix Hills) | Melvin Fowler | OL | 2002 | 10862 |
| Half Hollow Hills Central (Dix Hills) | Jasen Isom | RB | 2003 | 24385 |
| Half Hollow Hills West (Dix Hills) | Stephen Bowen | DL | 2006 | 8986 |
| Half Hollow Hills West (Dix Hills) | Damarr Aultman | WR | 2015 | 36146 |
| Half Hollow Hills West (Dix Hills) | Demarr Aultman (PR) | PR | 2017 | 36451 |
| Half Hollow Hills West (Dix Hills) | Demarr Aultman (KR) | KR | 2017 | 37277 |
| Hamburg (Hamburg) | Bob Leberman | DB | 1954 | 14364 |
| Hamilton (Brooklyn) | Art Carney | OL | 1925 | 10262 |
| Hamilton (Hamilton) | Red Chesbro | OL | 1938 | 16777 |
| Hamilton Institute (New York) | Joe Williams | OL | 1923 | 8785 |
| Harrison (Harrison) | Bruce Mesner | DL | 1987 | 24967 |
| Hastings (Hastings) | Ali Marpet | OL | 2015 | 3178 |
| Haverstraw (Haverstraw) | Nick Ryder | RB | 1963 | 14707 |
| Hempstead (Hempstead) | John Mackey | TE | 1963 | 493 |
| Hempstead (Hempstead) | Rob Moore | WR | 1990 | 1121 |
| Hempstead (Hempstead) | Tim Terry | LB | 1997 | 19205 |
| Henninger (Syracuse) | Ray Seals | DL | 1989 | 5412 |
| Henninger (Syracuse) | Mark Seals | DB | 1989 | 30895 |
| Henninger (Syracuse) | Terry Butler | RB | 2005 | 31100 |
| Henninger (Syracuse) | Will Brown | LB | 1994 | 32013 |
| Hicksville (Hicksville) | Ralph Sonntag | OL | 1970 | 31619 |
| High School of Commerce (New York) | Charlie Weber | OL | 1926 | 21535 |
| Hillcrest (Bedford Hills) | Walt Williams | DB | 1977 | 10100 |
| Holy Cross (Flushing) | Tom Costello | LB | 1964 | 17469 |
| Holy Cross (Queens) | Kevin Ogletree | WR | 2009 | 9786 |
| Holy Cross (Queens) | Dean Marlowe | DB | 2015 | 24080 |
| Holy Cross (Queens) | Tom Cassese | DB | 1967 | 25355 |
| Holy Family (South Huntington) | John Scully | OL | 1981 | 6940 |
| Holy Family (South Huntington) | Tom Donovan | WR | 1980 | 13915 |
| Holy Trinity (Hicksville) | Ralph Perretta | OL | 1975 | 12784 |
| Hornell (Hornell) | Bill Dugan | OL | 1981 | 22543 |
| Hudson (Hudson) | Ted Jornov | LB | 1974 | 30880 |
| Hudson (Hudson) | Rashad Barksdale | DB | 2007 | 39223 |
| Hudson (Montrose) | Mark Catano | DL | 1984 | 20394 |
| Huntington (Huntington) | Kurt Sohn | WR | 1981 | 8331 |
| Huntington (Huntington) | Kurt Sohn (PR) | PR | 1981 | 10108 |
| Huntington (Huntington) | Kurt Sohn (KR) | KR | 1981 | 15247 |
| Hutchinson (Buffalo) | Ed Doyle | OL | 1927 | 18129 |
| Hutchinson (Buffalo) | Jim Ailinger | OL | 1924 | 20647 |
| Iona Prep (New Rochelle) | Dick Ambrose | LB | 1975 | 3200 |
| Iona Prep (New Rochelle) | Chris Cooper (DB) | DB | 2018 | 39112 |
| Irondequoit (Irondequoit) | Andy Hendel | LB | 1984 | 18226 |
| Irving Prep (Tarrytown) | Dinty Moore | RB | 1927 | 10816 |
| Islip (Islip) | Darrell Adams | DL | 2006 | 29566 |
| Ithaca (Ithaca) | Tim Moresco | DB | 1977 | 20382 |
| Jamestown (Jamestown) | Jim McCusker | OL | 1958 | 5629 |
| Jamestown (Jamestown) | Stephen Carlson | TE | 2019 | 26697 |
| Jamesville-DeWitt (DeWitt) | Scott Schwedes (PR) | PR | 1987 | 7371 |
| Jamesville-DeWitt (DeWitt) | Robert Drummond | RB | 1989 | 12920 |
| Jamesville-DeWitt (DeWitt) | Scott Schwedes | WR | 1987 | 18967 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | John Brockington | RB | 1971 | 887 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | Otis Wilson | LB | 1980 | 1948 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | Earl Belgrave | OL | 1973 | 31582 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | Ebenezer Ogundeko | DL | 2018 | 38858 |
| John Jay (Katonah) | Mike J. Williams | WR | 1989 | 13364 |
| John Jay (Katonah) | Mike J. Williams (KR) | KR | 1989 | 16243 |
| John the Baptist (Massapequa Park) | John P. Sullivan | LB | 1979 | 23803 |
| Johnson City (Johnson City) | DaQuan Jones | DL | 2014 | 4698 |
| Johnson City (Johnson City) | Steve Chomyszak | DL | 1966 | 6357 |
| Kellenberg (Inwood) | Jon Harris | DL | 1997 | 24358 |
| Kelvin (Mount Vernon) | Jim Dufft | OL | 1921 | 13981 |
| Kenmore East (Tonawanda) | Jim Krieg | WR | 1972 | 23202 |
| Kennedy (Bronx) | Manny Castro | OL | 1997 | 31413 |
| Kensington (Buffalo) | Ed Hughes | DB | 1954 | 5598 |
| King (Brooklyn) | Eros Sanchez | QB | 1991 | 30478 |
| Kingston (Kingston) | Jerry Drake | DL | 1995 | 21562 |
| Kirby (Woodville) | Elvis Franks | DL | 1980 | 10452 |
| La Salle Academy (New York) | Charlie Trippi | RB | 1947 | 776 |
| La Salle Academy (New York) | Charlie Trippi (P) | P | 1947 | 7684 |
| La Salle Academy (New York) | Charlie Trippi (PR) | PR | 1947 | 7992 |
| La Salle Academy (New York) | Charlie Trippi (KR) | KR | 1947 | 8489 |
| La Salle Institute (Troy) | Butch Byrd | DB | 1964 | 1097 |
| La Salle Institute (Troy) | Butch Byrd (PR) | PR | 1964 | 8793 |
| La Salle Military Academy (Oakdale) | Andy Robustelli | DL | 1951 | 157 |
| La Salle Military Academy (Oakdale) | John Kissell | DL | 1948 | 3166 |
| Lackawanna (Lackawanna) | Ron Jaworski | QB | 1974 | 556 |
| Lackawanna (Lackawanna) | Mike Mamula | DL | 1995 | 6367 |
| Lackawanna (Lackawanna) | John Batorski | E | 1944 | 17484 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Sam DeLuca | OL | 1960 | 6306 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Alan Goldstein | WR | 1959 | 9116 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Andrew Lazarus | RB | 1983 | 19563 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | George Brancato | E | 1954 | 20112 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Willie Joyner | RB | 1984 | 21899 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Chris Williams (1998) | DL | 2020 | 25270 |
| Lafayette (Buffalo) | Lou Feist | E | 1924 | 11073 |
| Lafayette (Buffalo) | Bob Dugan | OL | 1964 | 35777 |
| Lafayette (Lafayette) | Gary Gibson | DL | 2005 | 15359 |
| Lancaster (Lancaster) | Faye Abbott | RB | 1921 | 3858 |
| Lancaster (Lancaster) | Hank Smith | OL | 1920 | 6239 |
| Lancaster (Lancaster) | Joe Andreessen | LB | 2024 | 24435 |
| LaSalle Institute (Troy) | Deval Glover | WR | 1989 | 36113 |
| Lawrence (Cedarhurst) | Lyle Alzado | DL | 1971 | 411 |
| Lawrence (Cedarhurst) | Shane Olivea | OL | 2004 | 10451 |
| Lawrence (Cedarhurst) | Chris Collier (KR) | KR | 2024 | 19667 |
| Lawrence (Cedarhurst) | Vaughn Sanders | RB | 2001 | 30407 |
| Lawrence (Cedarhurst) | Lou D'Agostino | RB | 1996 | 37105 |
| Lehman (Bronx) | Charles Puleri | QB | 1993 | 27439 |
| Lehman (Bronx) | Doug Marrone | OL | 1986 | 28863 |
| LeRoy (LeRoy) | Vin Scott | OL | 1947 | 16684 |
| Lewiston-Porter (Youngstown) | Daryl Johnston | RB | 1989 | 2851 |
| Lewiston-Porter (Youngstown) | Jason Johnson (LB) | LB | 2003 | 32312 |
| Liberty (Liberty) | Kaseem Sinceno | TE | 1998 | 16150 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Sid Youngelman | DL | 1955 | 2586 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Israel Abanikanda | RB | 2023 | 18892 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Marty Rosen | RB | 1965 | 29487 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Chris Martin (DB) | DB | 2004 | 30624 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Marty Rosen (PR) | PR | 1965 | 37526 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Chris Martin (KR) | KR | 2004 | 38416 |
| Lincoln (Yonkers) | Nealon Greene | QB | 1998 | 19351 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | Donnie Walker (PR) | PR | 1973 | 17441 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | Jeremy Ruckert | TE | 2022 | 18667 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | Bob Leahy | QB | 1971 | 21425 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | Donnie Walker | DB | 1973 | 23230 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | John Witkowski | QB | 1984 | 25040 |
| Lindenhurst (Lindenhurst) | Joe Levelis | OL | 1984 | 25051 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Pete Holohan | TE | 1981 | 1906 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Tim Green | LB | 1986 | 5421 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Chris Gedney | TE | 1993 | 11392 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Paul Tripoli | DB | 1987 | 21883 |
| Lockport (Lockport) | Ken A. Jones | RB | 1924 | 17870 |
| Lockport (Lockport) | Jeremy O'Day | OL | 1997 | 18185 |
| Lockport (Lockport) | David Fluellen | RB | 2014 | 19464 |
| Lockport (Lockport) | Daren Stone | DB | 2007 | 31955 |
| Locust Valley (Lattingtown) | John Mohring | LB | 1979 | 24029 |
| Long Beach (Long Beach) | Pete Johnson | RB | 1977 | 995 |
| Long Beach (Long Beach) | Scottie Graham | RB | 1992 | 8879 |
| Long Beach (Long Beach) | Wiley Pitts | WR | 1980 | 35382 |
| Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | Shamar Stephen | DL | 2014 | 8291 |
| Lyons (Lyons) | Roger Bernhardt | OL | 1973 | 25804 |
| Machine Trade (New York) | John Carlos | WR | 1970 | 34286 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Jack Grossman | RB | 1932 | 6019 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Harry Boatswain | OL | 1991 | 16859 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Kevin Francis | LB | 2016 | 23470 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Devale Ellis | WR | 2006 | 24203 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Hassan Probherbs | DB | 2001 | 38583 |
| Magnus (Bardonia) | Sarth Benoit | LB | 2005 | 30521 |
| Maine-Endwell (Endwell) | John Frieser | TE | 2004 | 32841 |
| Malverne (Malverne) | Wandy Williams (KR) | KR | 1969 | 14077 |
| Malverne (Malverne) | Wandy Williams | RB | 1969 | 19573 |
| Malverne (Malverne) | Miles McPherson | DB | 1982 | 24580 |
| Mamaroneck (Mamaroneck) | Billy Van Heusen (P) | P | 1968 | 2957 |
| Mamaroneck (Mamaroneck) | Billy Van Heusen | WR | 1968 | 5089 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Jim Brown | RB | 1957 | 2 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Jim Brown (KR) | KR | 1957 | 13958 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Jim Thorpe (WR) | WR | 1969 | 20609 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Jim Thorpe (P) | P | 1969 | 35633 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Jim Thorpe (KR) | KR | 1969 | 36925 |
| Manlius (Manlius) | Tom Rafferty | OL | 1976 | 2056 |
| Manlius (Manlius) | Vannie Albanese | RB | 1937 | 11194 |
| Manlius (Manlius) | Ray Purdin | RB | 1961 | 25765 |
| Manlius (Manlius) | Ray Purdin (KR) | KR | 1961 | 33771 |
| Manlius Military Academy (Manlius) | Art Spinney | OL | 1950 | 1222 |
| Manlius Military Academy (Manlius) | Herb Titmas | RB | 1931 | 11900 |
| Manual Training (Brooklyn) | Bob Beattie | OL | 1927 | 8396 |
| Manual Training (Brooklyn) | George Pease | RB | 1929 | 12578 |
| Manual Training (Brooklyn) | Bill Stephens | OL | 1926 | 22264 |
| Manual Training (Brooklyn) | Quentin Reynolds | OL | 1926 | 23361 |
| Massapequa (Massapequa) | Rich Baldinger | OL | 1982 | 6101 |
| Massapequa (Massapequa) | Brian Baldinger | OL | 1982 | 8936 |
| Massapequa (Massapequa) | Gary Baldinger | DL | 1986 | 18168 |
| McBurney (Manhattan) | Stuart Mitchell | QB | 1987 | 35647 |
| McQuaid (Rochester) | Bob Thomas | K | 1974 | 2713 |
| McQuaid (Rochester) | Eugene Goodlow | WR | 1982 | 8340 |
| McQuaid (Rochester) | Brian Parker | TE | 2015 | 25060 |
| Mechanicville (Mechanicville) | Joe Cocozzo | OL | 1993 | 13459 |
| Medina (Medina) | Ernie Clark | LB | 1963 | 4864 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Todd Sauerbrun | P | 1995 | 2230 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Chris Dieterich | OL | 1980 | 8220 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Joe Silipo | OL | 1980 | 16930 |
| Memorial (Amityville) | John Niland | OL | 1966 | 544 |
| Memorial (Amityville) | Darrel Young | RB | 2009 | 6490 |
| Memorial (Amityville) | Rob G. Carpenter | WR | 1991 | 14602 |
| Memorial (Amityville) | Eddie Hardaway | WR | 2000 | 30145 |
| Memorial (Elmont) | Marco Rivera | OL | 1997 | 1117 |
| Memorial (Elmont) | Gary Marangi | QB | 1974 | 12256 |
| Memorial (New Hyde Park) | Bob Avellini | QB | 1975 | 3956 |
| Memorial (New Hyde Park) | Pete Koch | DL | 1984 | 15898 |
| Mepham (Bellmore) | Amos Zereoue | RB | 1999 | 5520 |
| Mepham (Bellmore) | Donny Brady | DB | 1995 | 16323 |
| Mepham (Bellmore) | Ed Nickla | OL | 1955 | 18868 |
| Mepham (Bellmore) | Tyler Davis | TE | 2020 | 26142 |
| Meridian (Cato) | Josh Warner | OL | 2001 | 26552 |
| Midwood (Brooklyn) | Tony Colorito | DL | 1986 | 22337 |
| Midwood (Brooklyn) | Antonio Anderson | DL | 1997 | 27143 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Jeremy Horne | WR | 2010 | 26464 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Travon Van | RB | 2015 | 28175 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Ray Redziniak | OL | 2001 | 29328 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | DyShawn Davis | LB | 2016 | 30750 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Pierre Brilliant | OL | 1998 | 31404 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Brandon Washington | OL | 2012 | 34012 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Roman Grozman | OL | 2016 | 34750 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Travon Van (PR) | PR | 2015 | 36637 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Julien Laurent | DL | 2018 | 37037 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Artayvious Lynn | TE | 2021 | 37359 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Tim Gardner | OL | 2018 | 37688 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Travon Van (KR) | KR | 2015 | 37898 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Elorm Lumor | LB | 2022 | 38454 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Miles Frazier | OL | 2025 | 39362 |
| Milford Academy (New Berlin) | Kahzin Daniels | DL | 2019 | 40172 |
| Milfrod Academy (New Berlin) | Marquis Young | RB | 2019 | 38345 |
| Miller Place (Miller Place) | Rick Donnelly (P) | P | 1985 | 4470 |
| Mineola (Garden City Park) | Terry Kosens | DB | 1963 | 18635 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Wilbur Young | DL | 1971 | 3296 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Darren Carrington | DB | 1989 | 6716 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Joe Frank | OL | 1941 | 20645 |
| Morris (Bronx) | Dick Fishel | RB | 1933 | 12847 |
| Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | Art Donovan | DL | 1950 | 395 |
| Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | Vince Promuto | OL | 1960 | 2579 |
| Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | Bill O'Connor | E | 1948 | 10407 |
| Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | Caraun Reid | DL | 2014 | 20615 |
| Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | Terrence Patrick | DL | 2005 | 25612 |
| New Dorp (Staten Island) | Mike Siani | WR | 1972 | 2924 |
| New Dorp (Staten Island) | Hurvin McCormack | DL | 1994 | 15931 |
| New Dorp (Staten Island) | Frank Ferrara | DL | 1999 | 23910 |
| New Hartford (New Hartford) | Steve Cully | OL | 2003 | 30708 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Ray Rice | RB | 2008 | 585 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | George Starke | OL | 1973 | 2463 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Johnny Counts (KR) | KR | 1962 | 11736 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Jim Steen | OL | 1935 | 12757 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Bill Ellenbogen | OL | 1973 | 24869 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Johnny Counts | RB | 1962 | 25428 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Andre Douglas | OL | 2009 | 29610 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Ben Jefferson | OL | 1989 | 31694 |
| New Rochelles (New Rocelle) | Pat Morrison | DB | 1987 | 39182 |
| New Utrecht (Brooklyn) | Enio Conti | OL | 1941 | 6664 |
| New Utrecht (Brooklyn) | Sam Salemi | RB | 1928 | 11755 |
| New Utrecht (Brooklyn) | Stan Rosen | RB | 1929 | 17136 |
| New Utrecht (Brooklyn) | Bernie Kapitansky | OL | 1942 | 20178 |
| New Utrecht (Brooklyn) | Rony Barrow | DL | 2015 | 38745 |
| New York (New York) | Dave L. Smith | WR | 1970 | 7497 |
| New York Military Academy (Cornwall-on-Hudson) | Dutch Kitzmiller | RB | 1931 | 8394 |
| New York Military Academy (Cornwall-on-Hudson) | Ed Berrang | DL | 1949 | 9761 |
| New York Military Academy (Cornwall-on-Hudson) | Matt Joyce | OL | 1994 | 9864 |
| Newburgh Free Academy (Newburgh) | Bill Kerr | E | 1940 | 14100 |
| Newburgh Free Academy (Newburgh) | Byron Hemingway | LB | 1977 | 29344 |
| Newfield (Selden) | Rob Burnett | DL | 1990 | 1503 |
| Newfield (Selden) | Nick Bruckner | WR | 1983 | 22073 |
| Newfield (Selden) | Elijah Riley | DB | 2020 | 29511 |
| Newfield (Selden) | Mike Denimarck | LB | 1974 | 35215 |
| Newfield (Selden) | James Economou | OL | 2011 | 39502 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | James Starks | RB | 2010 | 5507 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | Bob Laraba | LB | 1960 | 10222 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | Dan DeSantis (KR) | KR | 1941 | 12842 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | Dan DeSantis | RB | 1941 | 12982 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | Bob Laraba (P) | P | 1960 | 16892 |
| Nichols (Buffalo) | Jesse Brown | RB | 1926 | 15742 |
| Niskayuna (Niskayuna) | Andre' Davis | WR | 2002 | 5845 |
| Niskayuna (Niskayuna) | Andre' Davis (KR) | KR | 2002 | 6081 |
| North (Binghamton) | Frank LoVuolo | E | 1949 | 21015 |
| North (Clarkstown) | Ed Rubbert | QB | 1987 | 26960 |
| North (Williamsville) | Chris Gronkowski | RB | 2010 | 18134 |
| North (Williamsville) | Dan Gronkowski | TE | 2009 | 23656 |
| North Babylon (North Babylon) | Guy Roberts | LB | 1972 | 9699 |
| North Babylon (North Babylon) | Ian Smart | RB | 2003 | 23880 |
| North Babylon (North Babylon) | Ian Smart (KR) | KR | 2003 | 26409 |
| North Babylon (North Babylon) | Ian Smart (PR) | PR | 2003 | 26432 |
| North Babylon (North Babylon) | Scooter Berry | DL | 2011 | 32199 |
| North Rockland (Thiells) | Derrick Lassic | RB | 1993 | 15131 |
| North Rockland (Thiells) | Molly McGee | RB | 1974 | 22222 |
| North Rockland (Thiells) | Wilky Bazile | DL | 1995 | 24533 |
| North Rockland (Thiells) | Dennis O'Sullivan | OL | 1999 | 31384 |
| North Rockland (Thiells) | Molly McGee (KR) | KR | 1974 | 36921 |
| North Shore (Glen Head) | Jim Romano | OL | 1982 | 19277 |
| North Shore (Glen Head) | Lyman Smith | DL | 1978 | 26618 |
| North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Tyvon Branch | DB | 2008 | 7025 |
| North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Eddie Doyle | E | 1924 | 7912 |
| North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Frank Matteo | OL | 1922 | 18277 |
| North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Dick Easterly | E | 1962 | 35262 |
| North Syracuse (North Syracuse) | Dick Easterly (PR) | PR | 1962 | 39342 |
| North Tonawanda (North Tonawanda) | Roman Piskor | OL | 1946 | 10069 |
| North Tonawanda (North Tonawanda) | Spin Roy | E | 1921 | 14114 |
| Northport (Northport) | Craig McEwen | TE | 1987 | 10642 |
| Northside (Corning) | Dick Riffle | RB | 1938 | 3794 |
| Northside (Corning) | Dick Riffle (KR) | KR | 1938 | 10469 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Dorsey Levens | RB | 1994 | 1584 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Doug Swift | LB | 1970 | 4911 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Keith Moody (PR) | PR | 1976 | 6769 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Keith Moody (KR) | KR | 1976 | 8033 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Keith Moody | DB | 1976 | 11947 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Derrick Gore | RB | 2019 | 16050 |
| Nottingham (Syracuse) | Carthell Flowers-Lloyd | LB | 2023 | 33479 |
| Nyack (Upper Nyack) | Roger Brown | DL | 1960 | 560 |
| Nyack (Upper Nyack) | Jimmy Ridlon | DB | 1957 | 3357 |
| Nyack (Upper Nyack) | George Jakowenko | K | 1974 | 11143 |
| Nyack (Upper Nyack) | Terrence Fede | DL | 2014 | 23420 |
| Oakfield (Oakfield) | Frank Trigilio | RB | 1946 | 20176 |
| Oceanside (Oceanside) | Jay Fiedler | QB | 1995 | 3128 |
| Ogdenburg Free Academy (Ogdensburg) | Charlie Gogolak | K | 1966 | 5376 |
| Ogdensburg Free Academy (Ogdensburg) | Pete Gogolak | K | 1964 | 2614 |
| Ogdensburg Free Academy (Ogdensburg) | Pete Gogolak (P) | P | 1964 | 17614 |
| Old Bethpage-Kennedy (Plainview) | Jamil Soriano | OL | 2003 | 29427 |
| Olympia (Rochester) | Marcus Wilson | RB | 1990 | 20272 |
| Olympia (Rochester) | Scott Virkus | DL | 1983 | 21461 |
| Oneonta (Oneonta) | Mark May | OL | 1981 | 2197 |
| Onondaga Central (Nedrow) | Mike Hart | RB | 2008 | 18668 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Ron Wolfley | RB | 1985 | 3212 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Jim Burt | DL | 1981 | 3521 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Craig Wolfley | OL | 1980 | 5256 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Josh Thomas | DL | 2004 | 18308 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Todd Schlopy | K | 1987 | 22518 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Jon Corto | DB | 2008 | 28376 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Larry Pfohl | OL | 1979 | 28753 |
| Oyster Bay (Oyster Bay) | Gary Silvestri | DL | 1979 | 33863 |
| Patchogue-Medford (Medford) | Tom O'Connor | P | 1987 | 23349 |
| Pearl River (Pearl River) | Danny Fortmann | OL | 1936 | 239 |
| Pearl River (Pearl River) | Harry Babcock | E | 1953 | 10215 |
| Peekskill (Peekskill) | Tre' Johnson | OL | 1994 | 6523 |
| Peekskill (Peekskill) | Doug Woodward | QB | 1980 | 14716 |
| Peekskill (Peekskill) | Bill Thomas (KR) | KR | 1972 | 15148 |
| Peekskill (Peekskill) | John Hasbrouck | RB | 1921 | 15878 |
| Peekskill (Peekskill) | Bill Thomas | RB | 1972 | 21695 |
| Penfield (Penfield) | Andre Forde | WR | 2003 | 31991 |
| Penn Yan Academy (Penn Yan) | Tony Collins | RB | 1981 | 1264 |
| Penn Yan Academy (Penn Yan) | Tony Collins (KR) | KR | 1981 | 11644 |
| Pine Bush (Pine Bush) | Mike Kiselak | OL | 1991 | 17581 |
| Pine Valley Central (South Dayton) | Bruce Bergey | DL | 1971 | 25232 |
| Pioneer (Yorkshire) | Cedric Gordon | WR | 1989 | 31503 |
| Pioneer (Yorkshire) | Cedric Gordon (KR) | KR | 1989 | 36284 |
| Plainview (Plainview) | Harry Blackney | RB | 1974 | 37778 |
| Poly Prep (Brooklyn) | Mike Stramiello | E | 1930 | 8148 |
| Poly Prep (Brooklyn) | Rich Kotite | TE | 1967 | 11781 |
| Poly Prep (Brooklyn) | Eric Olsen | OL | 2010 | 29299 |
| Port Chester (Port Chester) | Paul Costa | TE | 1965 | 3984 |
| Port Jefferson (Port Jefferson) | Les Goodman | RB | 1972 | 19330 |
| Port Washington (Port Washington) | John O'Leary | RB | 1976 | 26105 |
| Potsdam (Potsdam) | Trevor Scott | DL | 2008 | 16562 |
| Poughkeepsie (Poughkeepsie) | Monty Stickles | TE | 1960 | 2132 |
| Poughkeepsie (Poughkeepsie) | Reuben Frank | DL | 2016 | 33921 |
| Proctor (Utica) | Will Smith | DL | 2004 | 1452 |
| Proctor (Utica) | Corey Mitchell | OL | 2002 | 33440 |
| Queensbury (Queensbury) | Adam Terry | OL | 2005 | 22744 |
| Randolph (Randolph) | Marv Hubbard | RB | 1968 | 1165 |
| Rensselaer (Rensselaer) | Milt Graham | OL | 1956 | 16708 |
| Riordan (Highland) | Sal Marone | OL | 1943 | 16526 |
| Riverhead (Riverhead) | Ed Danowski | QB | 1934 | 1756 |
| Riverhead (Riverhead) | Ted Wegert | RB | 1955 | 7818 |
| Riverhead (Riverhead) | Ed Danowski (P) | P | 1934 | 13009 |
| Riverhead (Riverhead) | James Hill (TE) | TE | 1999 | 35490 |
| Riverhead (Riverhead) | Ethan Greenidge | OL | 2019 | 39158 |
| Riverside (Buffalo) | Scott Mersereau | DL | 1987 | 4042 |
| Riverside (Buffalo) | Joe Ehrmann | DL | 1973 | 4496 |
| Riverside (Buffalo) | Mike A. Williams | WR | 2010 | 7601 |
| Riverside (Buffalo) | Elmer Jones | OL | 1946 | 14325 |
| Rochester (Rochester) | Curt Kral | LB | 1973 | 34562 |
| Rome Free Academy (Rome) | Don Healy | DL | 1958 | 6411 |
| Rome Free Academy (Rome) | Charlie Havens | OL | 1930 | 10163 |
| Rome Free Academy (Rome) | Tom Myslinski | OL | 1992 | 22673 |
| Roosevelt (Bronx) | Clayton Heath (KR) | KR | 1974 | 34806 |
| Roosevelt (Roosevelt) | Elliott Fortune | DL | 1995 | 27860 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | Jimmy Kennedy | DL | 2003 | 14572 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | Terrence Wisdom | OL | 1995 | 23141 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | Clayton Heath | RB | 1974 | 25670 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | Doug Hogue | LB | 2011 | 27944 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | James H. Atkins | DL | 2003 | 28605 |
| Rush-Henrietta (Henrietta) | Matthew Snow | OL | 2020 | 36241 |
| Rye (Rye) | Beau Coash | TE | 1982 | 15699 |
| Sachem (Lake Ronkonkoma) | Jumbo Elliott | OL | 1988 | 3109 |
| Salamanca (Salamanca) | Chuck Crist | DB | 1972 | 5087 |
| Saratoga Springs (Saratoga Springs) | Anthony Weaver | DL | 2002 | 4950 |
| Saunders (Yonkers) | Rich Ranglin | OL | 2007 | 25020 |
| Saunders Trade & Tech (Yonkers) | Dave Costa | DL | 1963 | 1618 |
| Sayville (Sayville) | Mike Buck | QB | 1990 | 17033 |
| Sayville (Sayville) | Jack Coan | QB | 2022 | 29709 |
| Scarsdale (Scarsdale) | Rick Moser | RB | 1978 | 18449 |
| Scarsdale (Scarsdale) | Chris Cochrane | QB | 1991 | 31759 |
| Schenectady (Schenectady) | Bob O'Connor | OL | 1935 | 17626 |
| Seaford (Seaford) | Adam Bergen | TE | 2005 | 16854 |
| Seaford (Seaford) | Warren Koegel | OL | 1971 | 24724 |
| Seaford (Seaford) | James O'Hagan | OL | 2019 | 37655 |
| Seneca (Buffalo) | Van Jakes | DB | 1983 | 9284 |
| Seneca (Buffalo) | George Speth | OL | 1942 | 13971 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Hank Piro | E | 1941 | 12161 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Bruce Gehrke | E | 1948 | 14896 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Ty Gray | WR | 1979 | 20478 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Lloyd Harrison | DB | 2000 | 28790 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Jeremiah Pope | WR | 2004 | 38369 |
| Sewanhuka (Floral Park) | Paul Rochester | DL | 1960 | 3124 |
| Seward Park (New York) | Mike Jones (DL) | DL | 1987 | 33344 |
| Seward Park (New York) | Mike Jones (1964) | OL | 1987 | 36908 |
| Shaker (Latham) | Brandon Barlow | DL | 2022 | 25867 |
| Sheepshead Bay (Brooklyn) | Rashaad Coward | OL | 2017 | 25856 |
| Sherrill (Sherrill) | Charley Marshall | E | 1931 | 13838 |
| Solvay (Solvay) | Rocco Pirro | OL | 1940 | 3614 |
| Solvay (Solvay) | John Dooley | OL | 1922 | 12489 |
| Solvay (Solvay) | Roy Martineau | OL | 1923 | 13474 |
| Solvay (Solvay) | Joe Kowalewski | TE | 2007 | 23075 |
| Solvay (Solvay) | Al Romano | DL | 1977 | 29478 |
| South (Williamsville) | Jim Dombrowski | OL | 1986 | 3185 |
| South (Williamsville) | T.J. Cottrell | TE | 2004 | 33634 |
| South Dayton (South Dayton) | Bill Bergey | LB | 1969 | 171 |
| South Park (Buffalo) | Bill Pritchard | RB | 1927 | 9387 |
| South Park (Buffalo) | Jody Fortson | TE | 2019 | 21408 |
| South Park (Buffalo) | Joe Fortson | WR | 2019 | 24119 |
| South Shore (Brooklyn) | Travis Tucker | TE | 1985 | 20904 |
| South Shore (Brooklyn) | Al Steinfeld | OL | 1982 | 28576 |
| Southampton (Southampton) | Riley Biggs | OL | 1926 | 17258 |
| Spencerport (Spencerpot) | Vitaliy Gurman | OL | 2022 | 39518 |
| Spring Valley (Spring Valley) | Seth Joyner | LB | 1986 | 632 |
| Spring Valley (Spring Valley) | John Harvey | RB | 1990 | 18517 |
| Spring Valley (Spring Valley) | R-Kal Truluck | DL | 1997 | 18735 |
| Spring Valley (Spring Valley) | Charlie White | RB | 1977 | 20119 |
| Spring Valley (Spring Valley) | Phil Bogle | OL | 2003 | 23715 |
| Springfield (Springfield) | Shipwreck Kelly | RB | 1932 | 6894 |
| Springfield Gardens (Queens) | Eric Truvillion | WR | 1987 | 9656 |
| St. Agnes (South Hempstead) | Dan Gleason | DL | 1974 | 31542 |
| St. Alyoisius Academy (Schenectady) | Lee Riley | DB | 1955 | 2928 |
| St. Alyoisius Academy (Schenectady) | Lee Riley (PR) | PR | 1955 | 8760 |
| St. Alyoisius Academy (Schenectady) | Lee Riley (KR) | KR | 1955 | 12556 |
| St. Bernard's (Cohoes) | Furlong Flynn | OL | 1926 | 18651 |
| St. Dominic (Oyster Bay) | Dave Sullivan (OL) | OL | 1983 | 27252 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Dave Hack | OL | 1995 | 18873 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Luke Tasker | WR | 2013 | 21372 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Jim Kubiak | QB | 1995 | 22274 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Matt Jaworski | LB | 1991 | 28330 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Doug Worthington | DL | 2010 | 35151 |
| St. Francis (Athol Springs) | Kyle Smith (PR) | PR | 2006 | 35331 |
| St. Francis (Hamburg) | Jake Dolegala | QB | 2019 | 28353 |
| St. Francis (Hamburg) | Melique Straker | LB | 2024 | 35745 |
| St. Francis (Queens) | Bill Pickel | DL | 1983 | 3656 |
| St. Francis Prep (Fresh Meadows) | Rich Szaro | K | 1975 | 6669 |
| St. Francis Prep (Fresh Meadows) | Marco Battaglia | TE | 1996 | 7661 |
| St. Francis Prep (Fresh Meadows) | Mike Strofolino | LB | 1965 | 15270 |
| St. John the Baptist (West Islip) | Anton McKenzie | LB | 2006 | 19535 |
| St. John's Prep (Brooklyn) | Stu Clancy | RB | 1930 | 6151 |
| St. John's Prep (Brooklyn) | Paul Longua | E | 1929 | 9425 |
| St. John's Prep (Brooklyn) | Dick McGrath | OL | 1926 | 13717 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Vaughn Parker | OL | 1994 | 6339 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Naaman Roosevelt | WR | 2010 | 16342 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Sean Ryan | TE | 2004 | 17181 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Bryan Knight | LB | 2002 | 20593 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Bill Hurley | DB | 1982 | 23135 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Reed Bohovich | OL | 1962 | 25053 |
| St. Joseph's (Tonawanda) | Chad Kelly | QB | 2017 | 26785 |
| St. Lawrence (Brasher Falls) | Brian Sochia | DL | 1983 | 3849 |
| St. Mary's Academy (Glens Falls) | John Nolan Jr. | OL | 1948 | 10139 |
| St. Peter's (Staten Island) | Lewis Sanders | DB | 2000 | 15105 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas (Rochester) | Frank Varrichione | OL | 1955 | 1217 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas (Rochester) | Bob Bleier | QB | 1987 | 24206 |
| Stevenson (Bronx) | Kory Blackwell | DB | 1998 | 23684 |
| Stuyvesant (New York) | Dave Myers | OL | 1930 | 17134 |
| Stuyvesant (New York) | Lance Olssen | OL | 1968 | 28678 |
| Susquehanna Valley (Conklin) | Jon Kimmel | LB | 1983 | 20060 |
| Susquehanna Valley (Conklin) | Jamie Kimmel | LB | 1985 | 22267 |
| Sutherland (Pittsford) | Adam Podlesh | P | 2007 | 4659 |
| Sweet Home (Amherst) | Lance Shields | DB | 1982 | 14420 |
| Sweet Home (Amherst) | Keith O'Neil | LB | 2003 | 22114 |
| Syosset (Syosset) | Ed Newman | OL | 1973 | 768 |
| Syracuse (Syracuse) | J.R. Johnson | LB | 2002 | 30528 |
| Tappan Zee (Orangeburg) | Blaise Winter | DL | 1984 | 6229 |
| Tech (Brooklyn) | Roger Knight | LB | 2001 | 20929 |
| Tech (Brooklyn) | Mike D'Amato | DB | 1968 | 25940 |
| Tech (Brooklyn) | Mike D'Amato (KR) | KR | 1968 | 35880 |
| Tech (Brooklyn) | Keron Henry | WR | 2005 | 37049 |
| Textile (New York) | Joe Lamas | OL | 1942 | 19456 |
| The Fieldston School (Bronx) | Gus Ornstein | QB | 1999 | 32321 |
| The Manlius School (DeWitt) | Fran Morelli | OL | 1961 | 24814 |
| The Manlius School (Manlius) | Bob Rush (1951) | LB | 1974 | 35203 |
| Thomas (Webster) | Pat Kelly | TE | 1988 | 20308 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Ronnie Blye (KR) | KR | 1966 | 12763 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Owen Gill | RB | 1985 | 13585 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Devon Mitchell | DB | 1986 | 13924 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Ronnie Blye | RB | 1966 | 16316 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Terry Randolph | DB | 1977 | 25717 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Robert Bass | LB | 1994 | 32011 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Ben Kish | RB | 1940 | 4960 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Buck Gavin | RB | 1920 | 5200 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Rick Cassata | QB | 1968 | 19659 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Adewale Ogunleye | DL | 2001 | 1564 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Gus Edwards | RB | 2018 | 3722 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Joe Andruzzi | OL | 1998 | 5043 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Emmanuel Akah | OL | 2005 | 27314 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Abraham Kromah | LB | 2012 | 31978 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Anthony Coyle | OL | 2018 | 37670 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Derek Dennis | OL | 2012 | 20687 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Chukky Okobi | OL | 2001 | 21032 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Hergy Mayala | WR | 2019 | 25602 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Chuck Esty | OL | 1992 | 30781 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Shayne Skov | LB | 2014 | 33293 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Charles Spencer | OL | 2006 | 33705 |
| Trinity-Pawling (Pawling) | Austrian Robinson | DL | 2020 | 38605 |
| Trott (Niagara Falls) | Vince Mazza | E | 1945 | 18265 |
| Trott (Niagara Falls) | Willie Shine | RB | 1965 | 37803 |
| Troy (Troy) | Bill Leckonby | RB | 1939 | 10463 |
| Troy (Troy) | Bill Leckonby (PR) | PR | 1939 | 13419 |
| Tuckahoe (Eastchester) | Al Carapella | DL | 1951 | 3710 |
| Tuckahoe (Eastchester) | Eli Strand | OL | 1965 | 24889 |
| Tuckahoe (Eastchester) | Enoch Penney-Laryea | LB | 2022 | 34480 |
| Turner Carroll (Buffalo) | Corey Graham | DB | 2007 | 4433 |
| U.S. Military Academy Prep (West Point) | Brian Connolly | OL | 1999 | 31382 |
| U.S. Military Academy Prep (West Point) | Julius Warmsley | DL | 2014 | 33758 |
| U.S. Military Academy Prep (West Point) | Scott Flanick | OL | 2020 | 40213 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | Andrew Quarless | TE | 2010 | 10638 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | William Stanback | RB | 2017 | 18205 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | Tommy Campbell | DB | 1973 | 24996 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | Tommy Campbell (KR) | KR | 1973 | 34835 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | William Stanback (KR) | KR | 2017 | 35555 |
| Uniondale (Uniondale) | Sean Brown | OL | 2016 | 35985 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Chandler Jones | LB | 2012 | 637 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Mitch Olenski | OL | 1946 | 9541 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Isaiah Kacyvenski | LB | 2000 | 9748 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Ted Greene | LB | 1960 | 10779 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Arthur Jones | DL | 2010 | 16680 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | John Matisi | OL | 1943 | 18911 |
| US Military Academy Prep (West Point) | Dejoun Lee | RB | 2022 | 37392 |
| US Military Academy Prep (West Point) | Dejoun Lee (KR) | KR | 2022 | 39515 |
| Utica (Utica) | Ernest Jones | DL | 1994 | 26079 |
| Utica Free Academy (Utica) | Don Irwin | RB | 1936 | 7603 |
| Valley Central (Montgomery) | Mike McClearn | OL | 1983 | 23447 |
| Valley Stream (Valley Stream) | Stephen Boyd | LB | 1995 | 2309 |
| Vestal (Vestal) | Bob Campbell (PR) | PR | 1969 | 14355 |
| Vestal (Vestal) | Bob Campbell (KR) | KR | 1969 | 15975 |
| Vestal (Vestal) | Bob Campbell | WR | 1969 | 16755 |
| Vestal (Vestal) | John Schultz | WR | 1976 | 18525 |
| Vestal (Vestal) | John Moss | LB | 1973 | 35221 |
| Victor (Victor) | Seth Payne | DL | 1997 | 5136 |
| Vincentian Institute (Albany) | Ernie Stautner | DL | 1950 | 452 |
| Wagner (Staten Island) | Dennis McKnight | OL | 1982 | 4656 |
| Wallkill (Wallkill) | Ed Mooney | LB | 1968 | 10260 |
| Warsaw (Warsaw) | Ray Witter | E | 1921 | 14113 |
| Washington (Mohawk) | Thomas Stephens | TE | 1960 | 8562 |
| Washington (Mohawk) | Thomas Stephens (PR) | PR | 1960 | 14647 |
| Washington (New York) | Ed Smith | QB | 1936 | 10278 |
| Waterloo (Waterloo) | Derek Slywka | DB | 2024 | 30948 |
| Watertown (Watertown) | Al Fiorentino | OL | 1943 | 9472 |
| Watertown (Watertown) | Rocco Canale | OL | 1943 | 10073 |
| Watertown (Watertown) | Pat Killorin | OL | 1966 | 28795 |
| Watervliet (Watervliet) | Tim Sherwin | TE | 1981 | 6263 |
| Waverly (Waverly) | Les Goble | RB | 1954 | 9734 |
| Waverly (Waverly) | Les Goble (KR) | KR | 1954 | 11742 |
| Waverly (Waverly) | Les Goble (PR) | PR | 1954 | 13820 |
| West (Corning) | Doug Allen | LB | 1974 | 11691 |
| West (West Seneca) | Justin Strzelczyk | OL | 1990 | 7655 |
| West Babylon (West Babylon) | Jovan Belcher | LB | 2009 | 10095 |
| West Hempstead (West Hempstead) | Andrew Stewart | DL | 1989 | 18095 |
| West Hempstead (West Hempstead) | Don McPherson | QB | 1988 | 27521 |
| West Seneca (West Seneca) | Jeremy Kelley | WR | 2010 | 39815 |
| Westbury (Old Westbury) | Don Deskins | DL | 1960 | 9114 |
| Westbury (Old Westbury) | Henry Clement | TE | 1961 | 15981 |
| Westhampton Beach (Westhampton Beach) | Sean Farrell | OL | 1982 | 4889 |
| Westhampton Beach (Westhampton Beach) | Dan Jiggetts | OL | 1976 | 14814 |
| Westhampton Beach (Westhampton Beach) | Dylan Laube (KR) | KR | 2024 | 19150 |
| Westhampton Beach (Westhampton Beach) | Dylan Laube | RB | 2024 | 19386 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Art Monk | WR | 1980 | 581 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Dick Nolan | DB | 1954 | 2080 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Jay Saldi | TE | 1976 | 5536 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Carl Waite | RB | 1928 | 8122 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Lou Mark | OL | 1938 | 8128 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Sam Bowers | TE | 1987 | 10145 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Frank Briante | RB | 1929 | 11754 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Dennis Morgan (PR) | PR | 1974 | 12020 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Dennis Morgan (KR) | KR | 1974 | 13683 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Bob Horton | LB | 1964 | 15793 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Jim Gray | DB | 1965 | 25977 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Tom DePaso | LB | 1978 | 26223 |
| Whitman (Huntington Station) | Francesco Biancamano | P | 1998 | 30897 |
| Whitman (Huntington Station) | Tyreek Burwell | OL | 2015 | 37550 |
| Xaverian (Brooklyn) | Oday Aboushi | OL | 2014 | 17530 |
| Xavier (New York) | Jim Manning | RB | 1926 | 9321 |
| Xavier (New York) | Harry Kloppenberg | E | 1930 | 12199 |
| Xavier (New York) | Malik Fisher | DL | 2022 | 33640 |
| Yonkers (Yonkers) | Bill Garnjost | OL | 1921 | 15877 |
| Yorktown (Yorktown Heights) | Bill E. Brown | LB | 1960 | 8939 |
| Yorktown (Yorktown Heights) | Russ Swan | LB | 1986 | 30864 |
[Home] [Updates] [Sports] [Upcoming/Recent Events] [Polls] [Contact Us] [Links] [Our Facebook Page] [Our Twitter Page]