The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from New York High Schools Help Keep the Site Ad Free By Supporting us at Patreon
AinsworthSports.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from New York High Schools
Notes: This is a list of the greatest pro players who finished high school in this state.
What players did in high school or college does not factor into this list.
| High School | Athlete | POS | Rookie Yr | Overall Rank |
| Adams (Ozone Park) | Eddie Yost | 3B | 1944 | 1129 |
| Addison (Addison) | Jim Greengrass | LF | 1952 | 5399 |
| Adelphia Academy (Brooklyn) | Chuck Connors | 1B | 1949 | 12633 |
| All Hallows (Bronx) | James Norwood | RP | 2018 | 15567 |
| Allegany-Limestone (Allegany) | Shawn Dubin | RP | 2023 | 12565 |
| Amherst (Snyder) | Jonah Heim | C | 2020 | 3203 |
| Archbishop Molloy (Queens) | Mike Baxter | RF | 2010 | 15624 |
| Archbishop Stepniac (White Plains) | Brian Sweeney | RP | 2003 | 12647 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Tim Locastro | LF | 2017 | 15159 |
| Auburn (Auburn) | Kevin Polcovich | SS | 1997 | 15254 |
| Automotive Trades (Brooklyn) | Al Heist | CF | 1960 | 11704 |
| Averill Park (Sand Lake) | Roy Face | RP | 1953 | 591 |
| Aviation Tech (New York) | Whitey Ford | SP | 1950 | 97 |
| Aviation Tech (New York) | Lou Limmer | 1B | 1951 | 10107 |
| Baker (Baldwinsville) | Jason Grilli | RP | 2000 | 2764 |
| Baker (Baldwinsville) | Scott Blewett | RP | 2020 | 15097 |
| Baldwin (Long Island) | Al Severinsen | RP | 1969 | 7881 |
| Bay Shore (Bay Shore) | Greg Weissert | RP | 2022 | 13612 |
| Beach Channel (Rockaway) | Rolando Roomes | LF | 1988 | 13710 |
| Berkeley Carroll (Brooklyn) | Adam Ottavino | RP | 2010 | 3150 |
| Bethpage (Bethpage) | Joe Sambito | RP | 1976 | 1350 |
| Bishop Fallon (Buffalo) | Frank Bork | RP | 1964 | 8502 |
| Bishop Ford Central Catholic (Brooklyn) | John Halama | RP | 1998 | 4616 |
| Bishop Ludden (Syracuse) | John Johnstone | RP | 1993 | 6641 |
| Bishop O'Hara (Tonawanda) | Bill Scherrer | RP | 1982 | 5303 |
| Bishop Turner (Buffalo) | Phil Mankowski | 3B | 1976 | 14480 |
| Bowne (Flushing) | Heathcliff Slocumb | RP | 1991 | 2209 |
| Bowne (Flushing) | Steve Ratzer | RP | 1980 | 12370 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Tommy Davis | LF | 1959 | 1256 |
| Boys (Brooklyn) | Dom Zanni | RP | 1958 | 5058 |
| Brandeis (New York) | John Rodriguez | LF | 2005 | 15642 |
| Bridgehampton (Bridgehampton) | Carl Yastrzemski | LF | 1961 | 17 |
| Brighton (Brighton) | Ernie Clement | 2B | 2021 | 14051 |
| Broadalbin-Perth (Broadalbin) | Matt Gage | RP | 2022 | 15984 |
| Brockport (Brockport) | Andy Parrino | SS | 2011 | 16236 |
| Bronx (Bronx) | Bobby Bonilla | 3B | 1986 | 365 |
| Brooklyn (Brooklyn) | Turk Lown | RP | 1951 | 1733 |
| Bryant (Astoria) | Billy Loes | RP | 1950 | 1281 |
| Burke Catholic (Goshen) | Tim Hummel | 3B | 2003 | 16356 |
| Bushwick (Brooklyn) | Angelo LiPetri | RP | 1956 | 9793 |
| Camden (Camden) | Lynn Lovenguth | RP | 1955 | 9644 |
| Cardozo (Bayside) | Peter Munro | RP | 1999 | 8823 |
| Catholic (Kingston) | Joe Ausanio | RP | 1994 | 11148 |
| Catskill (Catskill) | Mickey Brantley | LF | 1986 | 11973 |
| Cayuga (Port Byron) | Mel Hall | LF | 1981 | 3667 |
| Center (Moriches) | Paul Gibson | RP | 1988 | 4019 |
| Central (Binghamton) | Rob Gardner | RP | 1965 | 5814 |
| Central (Hamburg) | Joe Hesketh | RP | 1984 | 2324 |
| Central (Horseheads) | Kirt Manwaring | C | 1987 | 3738 |
| Central (Ilion) | Boots Day | CF | 1969 | 11379 |
| Central (Lancaster) | Jack Phillips | 1B | 1947 | 8930 |
| Central (Marlboro) | Rob Bell | SP | 2000 | 5946 |
| Central (Milford) | Mike Barlow | RP | 1975 | 6223 |
| Central (Smithtown) | John Curtis | RP | 1970 | 2985 |
| Central (Valley Stream) | Tom A. Gorman | RP | 1952 | 2644 |
| Central (Whitehall) | Randy St. Claire | RP | 1984 | 6035 |
| Central (Windsor) | Joel Bennett | RP | 1998 | 13970 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Mike Proly | RP | 1976 | 3592 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | John Lannan | SP | 2007 | 5276 |
| Chaminade (Mineola) | Gene Larkin | 1B | 1987 | 7842 |
| Chenango Valley (Binghamton) | Justin Topa | RP | 2020 | 8351 |
| Childs (Bronx) | Bots Nekola | RP | 1929 | 9901 |
| Christ the King (Queens) | Steve Karsay | RP | 1993 | 3566 |
| Christ the King (Queens) | Allen Watson | SP | 1993 | 4034 |
| Christian Brothers (Albany) | John Cerutti | SP | 1985 | 4319 |
| Christian Brothers (Syracuse) | Frank Riccelli | RP | 1976 | 10718 |
| Churchville-Chili (Churchville) | Tim Redding | SP | 2001 | 4939 |
| Cicero-North Syracuse (Cicero) | Patrick Corbin | SP | 2012 | 1499 |
| Clarke (Westbury) | Ron Klimkowski | RP | 1969 | 6357 |
| Clarke (Westbury) | Bud Anderson | RP | 1982 | 8043 |
| Clarkstown North (New City) | Chris O'Grady | RP | 2017 | 14692 |
| Columbia (East Greenbush) | Kevin Smith | 3B | 2021 | 15538 |
| Commerce (New York) | Lou Gehrig | 1B | 1923 | 8 |
| Connetquot (Bohemia) | John Pacella | RP | 1977 | 8469 |
| Connetquot (Bohemia) | Sal Butera | C | 1980 | 14774 |
| Copiague (Copiague) | Hank Webb | SP | 1972 | 7990 |
| Cornwall (New Windsor) | Mike Bertotti | RP | 1995 | 12975 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Bobby Thomson | CF | 1946 | 453 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Hank Majeski | 3B | 1939 | 3302 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Anthony Varvaro | RP | 2010 | 10821 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Terry Crowley | RF | 1969 | 10924 |
| Curtis (Staten Island) | Frank Fernandez | C | 1967 | 11751 |
| Davis (Mount Vernon) | Ralph Branca | SP | 1944 | 694 |
| Deer Park (Deer Park) | Ray Searage | RP | 1981 | 4934 |
| Deer Park (Deer Park) | Joe Valentine | RP | 2003 | 14701 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Eddie Lopat | SP | 1944 | 768 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Gil Rondon | RP | 1976 | 9354 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Ozzie Virgil Sr. | 3B | 1956 | 11171 |
| DeWitt Clinton (Bronx) | Juan Perez (OF) | LF | 2013 | 16214 |
| Dolgeville (Dolgeville) | Hal Schumacher | SP | 1931 | 516 |
| East (Buffalo) | Buddy Rosar | C | 1939 | 835 |
| East (Buffalo) | Eddie Basinski | SS | 1944 | 10725 |
| East (Smithtown) | Frank Catalanotto | LF | 1997 | 6722 |
| East Hampton (East Hampton) | Ross Gload | 1B | 2000 | 11806 |
| East Islip (Islip Terrace) | Tony Graffanino | 2B | 1996 | 10593 |
| East Meadow (East Meadow) | Frank Viola | SP | 1982 | 439 |
| Eastchester (Eastchester) | John Doherty | 1B | 1992 | 6433 |
| Eastern District (Brooklyn) | Frankie Rodriguez | RP | 1995 | 6151 |
| Eleanor Roosevelt (New York) | Rocky Colavito | RF | 1955 | 275 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Waite Hoyt | SP | 1918 | 304 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Don McMahon | RP | 1957 | 966 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Tony Balsamo | RP | 1962 | 9941 |
| Erasmus Hall (Brooklyn) | Jonah Goldman | SS | 1928 | 10787 |
| Evander Childs (Bronx) | Joe Foy | 3B | 1966 | 5293 |
| Falconer (Falconer) | Hugh Bedient | SP | 1912 | 5637 |
| Farmingdale (Farmingdale) | Jack Lamabe | RP | 1962 | 3024 |
| Flushing (College Point) | Dave Von Ohlen | RP | 1983 | 7876 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Frankie Frisch | 2B | 1919 | 331 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Johnny Murphy | RP | 1932 | 1157 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Snuffy Stirnweiss | 2B | 1943 | 1388 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Rafael Novoa | RP | 1990 | 11991 |
| Fordham Prep (Bronx) | Andrew Velazquez | SS | 2018 | 15562 |
| Fort Plain (Fort Plain) | Bill Dahlen | SS | 1891 | 598 |
| Fox Lane (Bedford) | Henry Davis | RF | 2023 | 15518 |
| Fox Lane (Bedford) | Darin Mastroianni | RF | 2011 | 16242 |
| Franklin (Manhattan) | Duke Carmel | CF | 1959 | 13744 |
| Franklin Academy (Malone) | Tom Browning | SP | 1984 | 2059 |
| Franklin D. Roosevelt (Hyde Park) | Ricky Horton | RP | 1984 | 3674 |
| Franklin D. Roosevelt (Hyde Park) | Frank Cimorelli | RP | 1994 | 14473 |
| Franklin D. Roosevelt (Hyde Park) | Jeff Pierce | RP | 1995 | 15078 |
| Garden City (Garden City) | Matt Daley | RP | 2009 | 13324 |
| Glen Cove (Glen Cove) | Craig Hansen | RP | 2005 | 13030 |
| Glen Cove (Glen Cove) | Desi Wilson | 1B | 1996 | 16416 |
| Glens Falls (Glens Falls) | David Palmer | SP | 1978 | 2700 |
| Glens Falls (Glens Falls) | Dave LaPoint | SP | 1980 | 3208 |
| Gompers (Bronx) | Frank Malzone | 3B | 1955 | 846 |
| Grand Street (Brooklyn) | Jose Cuas | RP | 2022 | 13358 |
| Grand Street Campus (Brooklyn) | Dellin Betances | RP | 2011 | 1117 |
| Grand Street Campus (Brooklyn) | Williams Jerez | RP | 2018 | 15572 |
| Holy Cross (Flushing) | Dave Valle | C | 1984 | 3935 |
| Holy Trinity (Brooklyn) | Sal Campisi | RP | 1969 | 8557 |
| Horseheads (Horseheads) | Greg Keagle | SP | 1996 | 10891 |
| Hutchinson Central (Buffalo) | John Wyatt | RP | 1961 | 1014 |
| Iona Prep (New Rochelle) | Colin Moran | DH | 2016 | 9927 |
| Iona Prep (New Rochelle) | Joe La Sorsa | RP | 2023 | 15104 |
| Iona Prep (New Rochelle) | Brian Slocum | RP | 2006 | 15742 |
| Irving (Tarrytown) | Eddie Collins | 2B | 1906 | 26 |
| Islip (Islip) | Tom Veryzer | SS | 1973 | 9047 |
| Ithaca (Ithaca) | Harry L. Taylor | 1B | 1890 | 7339 |
| Ithaca (Ithaca) | Harry Taylor (1866) | 1B | 1890 | 9610 |
| Jamaica Inudstrial (Queens) | Mickey Harris | RP | 1940 | 1599 |
| Jay (Brooklyn) | Joe Pepitone | 1B | 1962 | 1093 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | Shawon Dunston | SS | 1985 | 3144 |
| Jefferson (Brooklyn) | Willie Lozado | 3B | 1984 | 16501 |
| Jefferson (Rochester) | Johnny Antonelli | SP | 1948 | 261 |
| John Jay (Hopewell Junction) | Joe Panik | 2B | 2014 | 5034 |
| Johnson City (Johnson City) | Ed Connolly | SP | 1964 | 8677 |
| Kellenberg Memorial (Uniondale) | Kevin McCarthy | RP | 2016 | 10544 |
| Kings Park (Kings Park) | Craig Biggio | 2B | 1988 | 185 |
| Kingston (Kingston) | Mike Ferraro | 3B | 1966 | 11574 |
| Kingston (Kingston) | Zack Short | SS | 2021 | 15547 |
| Kingston (Kingston) | Paul Runge | 3B | 1981 | 15718 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Sandy Koufax | SP | 1955 | 16 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | John Franco | RP | 1984 | 438 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Pete Falcone | SP | 1975 | 2698 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Al Ferrara | LF | 1963 | 8934 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Larry Yellen | RP | 1963 | 10988 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Mike Fiore | 1B | 1968 | 13131 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Kevin Baez | SS | 1990 | 16467 |
| Lafayette (Brooklyn) | Benny Distefano | 1B | 1984 | 16493 |
| Lancaster (Lancaster) | Pat Dobson | SP | 1967 | 1308 |
| Lane (Brooklyn) | Bob Grim | RP | 1954 | 1582 |
| LaSalle (Niagara Falls) | Rick Manning | CF | 1975 | 3886 |
| LaSalle Academy (Brooklyn) | John Candelaria | SP | 1975 | 424 |
| LaSalle Institute (Troy) | Zach Remillard | 2B | 2023 | 15960 |
| Lehman (Bronx) | T.J. Rivera | 2B | 2016 | 15590 |
| Lewis (Queens) | Ed Glynn | RP | 1975 | 4393 |
| Lewis (Queens) | Mike Jorgensen | 1B | 1968 | 6479 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Saul Rogovin | SP | 1949 | 3093 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Lee Mazzilli | CF | 1976 | 3443 |
| Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Nelson Figueroa | RP | 2000 | 5258 |
| Linton (Schenectady) | Bill Connors | RP | 1966 | 9137 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Scott Cassidy | RP | 2002 | 10817 |
| Liverpool (Liverpool) | Chris Jones | RF | 1991 | 13950 |
| Long Beach (Lido Beach) | Don Taussig | LF | 1958 | 13004 |
| Madison (Brooklyn) | Joe Torre | C | 1960 | 143 |
| Mahopac (Mahopac) | Dave Fleming | SP | 1991 | 6281 |
| Mahopac (Mahopac) | Brendan White | RP | 2023 | 13175 |
| Mahopac (Mahopac) | C.J. Riefenhauser | RP | 2014 | 16175 |
| Mamaroneck (Mamaroneck) | Scott Leius | 3B | 1990 | 10261 |
| Manhasset (Manhasset) | Danny Barnes | RP | 2016 | 12316 |
| Mann (Riverdale) | Harrison Bader | CF | 2017 | 7348 |
| Maple Hill (Castleton-on-Hudson) | Jaime Schultz | RP | 2018 | 15323 |
| Marlboro Central (Newburgh) | Dee Brown | LF | 1998 | 14539 |
| Marshall (Rochester) | Bob Keegan | SP | 1953 | 3075 |
| Massena (Massena) | Jim Deshaies | SP | 1984 | 2278 |
| McClancy Memorial (Flushing) | Don Cooper | RP | 1981 | 10564 |
| McKee Tech (Staten Island) | Karl Drews | RP | 1946 | 2846 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Steven Matz | SP | 2015 | 3747 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Ben Brown | SP | 2024 | 12524 |
| Melville (East Setauket) | Anthony Kay | SP | 2019 | 13021 |
| Memorial (Floral Park) | Steve Falteisek | RP | 1997 | 15434 |
| Memorial (New Hyde Park) | Gary Christenson | RP | 1979 | 10481 |
| Memorial (Pelham) | Gary Scott | 3B | 1991 | 16456 |
| Mepham (North Bellmore) | Jason Foley | RP | 2021 | 9888 |
| Mepham (North Bellmore) | John Morris (OF) | RF | 1986 | 14771 |
| Middletown (Middletown) | Mike Aviles | SS | 2008 | 8475 |
| Mineville (Witherbee) | Johnny Podres | SP | 1953 | 855 |
| Minisink Valley (Slate Hill) | Dave Telgheder | SP | 1993 | 7841 |
| Minisink Valley (State Hill) | Josh Walker | RP | 2023 | 15520 |
| Minoa (East Syracuse) | Todd Williams | RP | 1995 | 10035 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Hank Greenberg | 1B | 1930 | 27 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Ed Kranepool | 1B | 1962 | 3479 |
| Monroe (Bronx) | Randy Ruiz | DH | 2008 | 16299 |
| Monsignor Farrell (Staten Island) | Tom Cosgrove | RP | 2023 | 12050 |
| Moore (Central Square) | Tom Murphy (1991) | C | 2015 | 13247 |
| Morris (Bronx) | Al Kellett | RP | 1923 | 9904 |
| Morris (Bronx) | Jack Coffey | SS | 1909 | 12897 |
| Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon) | Ken Singleton | RF | 1970 | 324 |
| Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon) | Roy Smith | RP | 1984 | 5171 |
| Mynderse Academy (Seneca Falls) | Charlie Boardman | RP | 1913 | 8978 |
| New Hartford (New Hartford) | Andy Van Slyke | CF | 1983 | 680 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Josiah Gray | SP | 2021 | 5701 |
| New Rochelle (New Rochelle) | Tom Koehler | SP | 2012 | 6188 |
| New York Vocational (Jamaica) | Rusty Torres | RF | 1971 | 12265 |
| Newburgh (Newburgh) | Bill Short | RP | 1960 | 6871 |
| Newburgh Free Academy (Newburgh) | Willie Fraser | RP | 1986 | 5048 |
| Niagara Falls (Niagara Falls) | Vince Molyneaux | RP | 1917 | 7675 |
| North (Clarkstown) | Will Cunnane | RP | 1997 | 8493 |
| North (Commack) | Pete Harnisch | SP | 1988 | 1030 |
| North (Syracuse) | Dave Giusti | RP | 1962 | 751 |
| North Shore (Glen Head) | Mike Armstrong | RP | 1980 | 4961 |
| Notre Dame (Utica) | Mark Lemke | 2B | 1988 | 7682 |
| Oceanside (Oceanside) | Dennis Leonard | SP | 1974 | 1262 |
| Oceanside (Oceanside) | John Frascatore | RP | 1994 | 6684 |
| Oceanside (Oceanside) | John Costello | RP | 1988 | 7484 |
| Oneonta (Oneonta) | Clay Bellinger | CF | 1999 | 16389 |
| Orchard Park (Orchard Park) | Dave Hollins | 3B | 1990 | 3781 |
| Oriskany Falls (Oriskany Falls) | Karl Spooner | SP | 1954 | 7341 |
| Park West (New York) | Devon White | CF | 1985 | 1023 |
| Patchogue-Medford (Medford) | Marcus Stroman | SP | 2014 | 998 |
| Patchogue-Medford (Medford) | Jeff Schaefer | SS | 1994 | 15677 |
| Pierson (Sag Harbor) | Kyle McGowin | RP | 2018 | 14544 |
| Pine Bush (Pine Bush) | Joe Nathan | RP | 1999 | 315 |
| Pittsford-Mendon (Pittsford) | Danny Mendick | SS | 2019 | 14311 |
| Port Richmond (Staten Island) | Cliff Brantley | RP | 1991 | 11002 |
| Poughkeepsie (Poughkeepsie) | Fred Lasher | RP | 1963 | 4975 |
| Proctor (Utica) | Dave Cash | 2B | 1969 | 1459 |
| PS #2 (Brooklyn) | Jackie Hayes (1861) | CF | 1882 | 8129 |
| Queensbury (Queensbury) | Brendan Harris | SS | 2004 | 11128 |
| Regis (New York) | Declan Cronin | RP | 2023 | 14212 |
| Richmond Hill (Queens) | Phil Rizzuto | SS | 1941 | 648 |
| Richmond Hill (Queens) | Marius Russo | SP | 1939 | 2724 |
| Rocky Point (Rocky Point) | Danny Burawa | RP | 2015 | 16150 |
| Rome Free Academy (Rome) | Archi Cianfrocco | 1B | 1992 | 12936 |
| Roosevelt (Yonkers) | Hank Fischer | RP | 1962 | 4062 |
| Ross (Brentwood) | Jim Dougherty | RP | 1995 | 12167 |
| Rye (Rye) | B.J. Surhoff | LF | 1987 | 1521 |
| Rye (Rye) | George Kirby | SP | 2022 | 3766 |
| Rye (Rye) | Eric Junge | RP | 2002 | 14975 |
| Sachem (Lake Ronkonkoma) | Neal Heaton | SP | 1982 | 3029 |
| Sachem North (Lake Ronkonkoma) | Mike Parisi | RP | 2008 | 16297 |
| Saratoga Central Catholic (Saratoga Springs) | Tim Stauffer | RP | 2005 | 5489 |
| Schenectady (Schenectady) | Bill Cunningham (2B) | 2B | 1910 | 10381 |
| Schenectady (Schenectady) | Casper Wells | RF | 2010 | 14577 |
| Seaford (Seaford) | Jim Norris | RF | 1977 | 11403 |
| Seaford (Seaford) | Sean Nolin | SP | 2013 | 13642 |
| Seton Catholic (Binghamton) | John Pawlowski | RP | 1987 | 13588 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Pete Richert | RP | 1962 | 867 |
| Sewanhaka (Floral Park) | Bob Giallombardo | SP | 1958 | 9018 |
| Seward Park (Seward Park) | Edwin Almonte | RP | 2003 | 15832 |
| Shaker (Latham) | Jeff Hoffman | RP | 2016 | 4108 |
| Shaker (Latham) | Tommy Kahnle | RP | 2014 | 4846 |
| Sheepshead Bay (Brooklyn) | Rico Petrocelli | SS | 1963 | 1549 |
| Sheepshead Bay (Brooklyn) | Frank Brooks | RP | 2004 | 15265 |
| Shenendehowa (Clifton Park) | Ian Anderson | SP | 2020 | 6744 |
| Shenendehowa (Clifton Park) | Dan Peltier | RF | 1992 | 16449 |
| Shoreham-Wading (Shoreham) | Keith Osik | C | 1996 | 12932 |
| Smithtown East (St. James) | Jim Mecir | RP | 1995 | 3579 |
| South (Commack) | Don DeMola | RP | 1974 | 6561 |
| South (Great Neck) | Charlie Williams | RP | 1971 | 3678 |
| South Park (Buffalo) | Warren Spahn | SP | 1942 | 48 |
| South Shore (Brooklyn) | Wayne Rosenthal | RP | 1991 | 10782 |
| St. Dominic (Oyster Bay) | Reiss Knehr | RP | 2021 | 15499 |
| St. Francis (Colden) | Kevin Kobel | SP | 1973 | 6307 |
| St. Helena (Bronx) | Mike Nagy | SP | 1969 | 6470 |
| St. John the Baptist (West Islip) | John Habyan | RP | 1985 | 3925 |
| St. John the Baptist (West Islip) | Logan O'Hoppe | C | 2022 | 10629 |
| St. John the Baptist (West Islip) | Joe Palumbo | SP | 2019 | 14250 |
| St. John's Military Academy (Syracuse) | Iron Davis | SP | 1912 | 6764 |
| St. Johnsville (St. Johnsville) | Roger Weaver | RP | 1980 | 8295 |
| St. Joseph by the Sea (Staten Island) | Matt Festa | RP | 2018 | 13842 |
| St. Joseph's (Buffalo) | Frank Kreutzer | RP | 1962 | 7416 |
| St. Michael's (Brooklyn) | Rinty Monahan | RP | 1953 | 9308 |
| St. Peter's (Staten Island) | Larry Bearnarth | RP | 1963 | 5696 |
| Suffern (Suffern) | Walt Weiss | SS | 1987 | 4988 |
| Sutherland (Pittsford) | Mike Jones | RP | 1980 | 8537 |
| Syracuse (Syracuse) | Frank Scanlan | RP | 1909 | 13749 |
| Technical (Brooklyn) | Tommy Holmes | RF | 1942 | 621 |
| Technical (Brooklyn) | Jim Prendergast | RP | 1948 | 10237 |
| Telecommunication Arts & Tech (Brooklyn) | Joshua Palacios | RF | 2021 | 15864 |
| Telecommunications (Brooklyn) | James Jones | CF | 2014 | 15506 |
| The Berkeley Carroll School (Brooklyn) | Richie Palacios | 2B | 2022 | 14944 |
| Theodore Roosevelt (Bronx) | Ben Oglivie | LF | 1971 | 1257 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Sid Gordon | LF | 1941 | 721 |
| Tilden (Brooklyn) | Willie Randolph | 2B | 1975 | 919 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Dave Geisel | RP | 1978 | 5092 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Jim Britton | RP | 1967 | 6613 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Jim Britt | SP | 1872 | 8679 |
| Tonawanda (Tonawanda) | Glen Cook | SP | 1985 | 12228 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Jason Marquis | SP | 2000 | 2481 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Rich Scheid | RP | 1992 | 12701 |
| Tottenville (Staten Island) | Zack Granite | CF | 2017 | 16118 |
| Trinity (Pawling) | Mo Vaughn | 1B | 1991 | 460 |
| Trinity (Pawling) | Kirk McCaskill | SP | 1985 | 2697 |
| Troy (Troy) | Billy Harrell | SS | 1955 | 11857 |
| Truman (Bronx) | Stan Jefferson | CF | 1986 | 13989 |
| Union (Endicott) | Johnny Logan | SS | 1951 | 1527 |
| Union-Endicott (Endicott) | Jim Johnson | RP | 2006 | 1669 |
| Valhalla (Valhalla) | Keefe Cato | RP | 1983 | 12799 |
| Valley Central (Montgomery) | Matt Morris | SP | 1997 | 1357 |
| Valley Central (Montgomery) | Jason Motte | RP | 2008 | 4232 |
| Valley Central (Montgomery) | James Karinchak | RP | 2019 | 7642 |
| Valley Stream (Valley Stream) | Conrad Cardinal | RP | 1963 | 10784 |
| Wagner (Staten Island) | Frank Menechino | 2B | 1999 | 12346 |
| Wantaugh (Wantaugh) | Chuck Smith | SP | 2000 | 8007 |
| Washington (New York) | Manny Ramirez | LF | 1993 | 92 |
| Washington (New York) | Arnie Portocarrero | SP | 1954 | 3470 |
| Washington (New York) | Alex Arias | SS | 1992 | 12202 |
| Washington (Washington Heights) | Rod Carew | 1B | 1967 | 71 |
| West Babylon (West Babylon) | Billy Koch | RP | 1999 | 2580 |
| West Genesee (Camillus) | Frank DiPino | RP | 1981 | 2699 |
| West Islip (West Islip) | Nick Tropeano | RP | 2014 | 8223 |
| Westbury (Westbury) | Tom Donohue | C | 1979 | 15719 |
| Westhill (Syracuse) | Dave Lemanczyk | SP | 1973 | 3369 |
| Westinghouse (Brooklyn) | Joe Pignatano | C | 1957 | 10670 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Art Schult | 1B | 1953 | 11532 |
| White Plains (White Plains) | Sal Yvars | C | 1947 | 12544 |
| Williamsville (Williamsville) | Matt Winters | RF | 1989 | 16474 |
| Wilson (Wilson) | Steve Geltz | RP | 2012 | 12687 |
| Wingate (Brooklyn) | Frank Tepedino | 1B | 1967 | 14896 |
| Woodmere (Woodmere) | Les Howe | RP | 1923 | 8977 |
| Xaverian (Brooklyn) | Rich Aurilia | SS | 1995 | 3780 |
| Xaverian (Brooklyn) | Frank Seminara | SP | 1992 | 10118 |
| Yonkers (Yonkers) | Dell Alston | RF | 1977 | 16548 |
[Home] [Updates] [Sports] [Upcoming/Recent Events] [Polls] [Contact Us] [Links] [Our Facebook Page] [Our Twitter Page]