The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from New York Help Keep the Site Ad Free By Supporting us at Patreon
AinsworthSports.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from New York
Notes: This is a list of the greatest pro players that were born in this state.
Where players grew up or went to school does not factor into this list.
| Rnk | Athlete | POS | Rookie Yr | Birthplace | Overall Rank |
| 1 | Lou Gehrig | 1B | 1923 | New York | 8 |
| 2 | Alex Rodriguez | SS | 1994 | New York | 12 |
| 3 | Sandy Koufax | SP | 1955 | Brooklyn | 16 |
| 4 | Carl Yastrzemski | LF | 1961 | Southampton | 17 |
| 5 | Eddie Collins | 2B | 1906 | Millerton | 26 |
| 6 | Hank Greenberg | 1B | 1930 | New York | 27 |
| 7 | Warren Spahn | SP | 1942 | Buffalo | 48 |
| 8 | Whitey Ford | SP | 1950 | New York | 97 |
| 9 | Dan Brouthers | 1B | 1879 | Sylvan Lake | 101 |
| 10 | Old Hoss Radbourn | SP | 1880 | Rochester | 116 |
| 11 | Wee Willie Keeler | RF | 1892 | Brooklyn | 125 |
| 12 | King Kelly | RF | 1878 | Troy | 136 |
| 13 | Mickey Welch | SP | 1880 | Brooklyn | 142 |
| 14 | Joe Torre | C | 1960 | Brooklyn | 143 |
| 15 | Jim Palmer | SP | 1965 | New York | 146 |
| 16 | Craig Biggio | 2B | 1988 | Smithtown | 185 |
| 17 | Cy Seymour | CF | 1896 | Albany | 228 |
| 18 | Edgar Martinez | DH | 1987 | New York | 247 |
| 19 | Deacon White | 3B | 1871 | Caton | 257 |
| 20 | Johnny Antonelli | SP | 1948 | Rochester | 261 |
| 21 | Rocky Colavito | RF | 1955 | New York | 275 |
| 22 | Jim Whitney | SP | 1881 | Conklin | 279 |
| 23 | George J. Burns | LF | 1911 | Utica | 302 |
| 24 | Waite Hoyt | SP | 1918 | Brooklyn | 304 |
| 25 | Ken Singleton | RF | 1970 | New York | 324 |
| 26 | Frankie Frisch | 2B | 1919 | Bronx | 331 |
| 27 | Wally Schang | C | 1913 | South Wales | 337 |
| 28 | Jimmy Collins | 3B | 1895 | Buffalo | 339 |
| 29 | Orel Hershiser | SP | 1983 | Buffalo | 343 |
| 30 | Bobby Bonilla | 3B | 1986 | Bronx | 365 |
| 31 | George Davis | SS | 1890 | Cohoes | 417 |
| 32 | John Candelaria | SP | 1975 | New York | 424 |
| 33 | John Franco | RP | 1984 | Brooklyn | 438 |
| 34 | Frank Viola | SP | 1982 | Hempstead | 439 |
| 35 | Sal Maglie | SP | 1945 | Niagara Falls | 449 |
| 36 | Joe Start | 1B | 1871 | New York | 492 |
| 37 | Hal Schumacher | SP | 1931 | Hinckley | 516 |
| 38 | Frank McCormick | 1B | 1934 | New York | 533 |
| 39 | Roy Face | RP | 1953 | Stephentown | 591 |
| 40 | Bill Dahlen | SS | 1891 | Nelliston | 598 |
| 41 | Tommy Leach | CF | 1898 | French Creek | 609 |
| 42 | Edsall Walker | SP | 1936 | Catskill | 620 |
| 43 | Tommy Holmes | RF | 1942 | Brooklyn | 621 |
| 44 | Phil Rizzuto | SS | 1941 | Brooklyn | 648 |
| 45 | Babe Herman | RF | 1926 | Buffalo | 666 |
| 46 | Andy Van Slyke | CF | 1983 | Utica | 680 |
| 47 | Ralph Branca | SP | 1944 | Mount Vernon | 694 |
| 48 | Sid Gordon | LF | 1941 | Brooklyn | 721 |
| 49 | Ezra Sutton | 3B | 1871 | Seneca Falls | 746 |
| 50 | Dave Giusti | RP | 1962 | Seneca Falls | 751 |
| 51 | Eddie Lopat | SP | 1944 | New York | 768 |
| 52 | Lou Whitaker | 2B | 1977 | Brooklyn | 814 |
| 53 | Buddy Rosar | C | 1939 | Buffalo | 835 |
| 54 | Frank Malzone | 3B | 1955 | Bronx | 846 |
| 55 | Johnny Podres | SP | 1953 | Witherbee | 855 |
| 56 | Tom York | LF | 1871 | Brooklyn | 864 |
| 57 | Pete Richert | RP | 1962 | Floral Park | 867 |
| 58 | Heinie Zimmerman | 3B | 1907 | New York | 877 |
| 59 | Bill Dinneen | SP | 1898 | Syracuse | 885 |
| 60 | Paul Lo Duca | C | 1998 | Brooklyn | 887 |
| 61 | Bill Hallahan | SP | 1925 | Binghamton | 922 |
| 62 | Bid McPhee | 2B | 1882 | Massena | 932 |
| 63 | John McGraw | 3B | 1891 | Truxton | 934 |
| 64 | Don McMahon | RP | 1957 | Brooklyn | 966 |
| 65 | Nick Markakis | RF | 2006 | Glen Cove | 976 |
| 66 | Marcus Stroman | SP | 2014 | Medford | 998 |
| 67 | George Earnshaw | SP | 1928 | New York | 1029 |
| 68 | Pete Harnisch | SP | 1988 | Commack | 1030 |
| 69 | Heinie Groh | 3B | 1912 | Rochester | 1052 |
| 70 | Joe Pepitone | 1B | 1962 | Brooklyn | 1093 |
| 71 | Dellin Betances | RP | 2011 | New York | 1117 |
| 72 | Eddie Yost | 3B | 1944 | Brooklyn | 1129 |
| 73 | Jerry Denny | 3B | 1881 | New York | 1140 |
| 74 | Stump Weidman | SP | 1880 | Rochester | 1147 |
| 75 | Hooks Wiltse | SP | 1904 | Hamilton | 1154 |
| 76 | Johnny Murphy | RP | 1932 | New York | 1157 |
| 77 | Joe Hornung | LF | 1879 | Carthage | 1197 |
| 78 | Frank Schulte | RF | 1904 | Cocheton | 1219 |
| 79 | Richie Zisk | RF | 1971 | Brooklyn | 1248 |
| 80 | Tommy Davis | LF | 1959 | Brooklyn | 1256 |
| 81 | Dennis Leonard | SP | 1974 | Brooklyn | 1262 |
| 82 | Jack Burdock | 2B | 1872 | Brooklyn | 1273 |
| 83 | Howard Ehmke | SP | 1915 | Silver Creek | 1278 |
| 84 | Billy Loes | RP | 1950 | Long Island City | 1281 |
| 85 | Mike J. Griffin | CF | 1887 | Utica | 1292 |
| 86 | Harry Howell | SP | 1898 | Brooklyn | 1298 |
| 87 | Joe Judge | 1B | 1915 | Brooklyn | 1303 |
| 88 | Pat Dobson | SP | 1967 | Buffalo | 1308 |
| 89 | Herb Score | SP | 1955 | Rosedale | 1311 |
| 90 | Joe Sambito | RP | 1976 | Brooklyn | 1350 |
| 91 | Matt Morris | SP | 1997 | Middletown | 1357 |
| 92 | Johnny Evers | 2B | 1902 | Troy | 1362 |
| 93 | Dick Rudolph | SP | 1910 | New York | 1363 |
| 94 | Snuffy Stirnweiss | 2B | 1943 | New York | 1388 |
| 95 | Bob Ferguson | 3B | 1871 | Brooklyn | 1390 |
| 96 | A.J. Pierzynski | C | 1998 | Bridgehampton | 1405 |
| 97 | Patsy Dougherty | LF | 1902 | Andover | 1420 |
| 98 | Dave Cash | 2B | 1969 | Utica | 1459 |
| 99 | Bob Shaw | SP | 1957 | Bronx | 1472 |
| 100 | Red Ryan | SP | 1919 | Brooklyn | 1492 |
| 101 | Patrick Corbin | SP | 2012 | Clay | 1499 |
| 102 | Bill Bernhard | SP | 1899 | Clarence | 1510 |
| 103 | B.J. Surhoff | LF | 1987 | Bronx | 1521 |
| 104 | Fats Jenkins | LF | 1920 | New York | 1524 |
| 105 | Johnny Logan | SS | 1951 | Endicott | 1527 |
| 106 | Rico Petrocelli | SS | 1963 | Brooklyn | 1549 |
| 107 | John Tudor | SP | 1979 | Schenectady | 1552 |
| 108 | Ted Wilks | RP | 1944 | Fulton | 1559 |
| 109 | Bob Grim | RP | 1954 | New York | 1582 |
| 110 | Mickey Harris | RP | 1940 | New York | 1599 |
| 111 | Tony Cuccinello | 2B | 1930 | Long Island City | 1615 |
| 112 | Sean Murphy | C | 2019 | Peekskill | 1644 |
| 113 | Jim Johnson | RP | 2006 | Johnson City | 1669 |
| 114 | Mickey McDermott | SP | 1948 | Poughkeepsie | 1699 |
| 115 | George Mogridge | SP | 1911 | Rochester | 1707 |
| 116 | Mike Remlinger | RP | 1991 | Middletown | 1725 |
| 117 | Turk Lown | RP | 1951 | Brooklyn | 1733 |
| 118 | Doggie Miller | C | 1884 | Brooklyn | 1734 |
| 119 | Kid Carsey | SP | 1891 | New York | 1735 |
| 120 | John Clapp | C | 1872 | Ithaca | 1754 |
| 121 | Raul Ibanez | LF | 1996 | New York | 1760 |
| 122 | Jim Konstanty | RP | 1944 | Strykersville | 1762 |
| 123 | Pete Mikkelsen | RP | 1964 | Staten Island | 1776 |
| 124 | Tom Ferrick | RP | 1941 | New York | 1778 |
| 125 | Jimmy Ring | SP | 1917 | Brooklyn | 1885 |
| 126 | Hugh McQuillan | SP | 1918 | New York | 1933 |
| 127 | George McQuillan | SP | 1907 | Brooklyn | 1935 |
| 128 | Pete Hotaling | CF | 1879 | Mohawk | 1984 |
| 129 | Larry Corcoran | SP | 1880 | Brooklyn | 2086 |
| 130 | Hal White | RP | 1941 | Utica | 2157 |
| 131 | Casey Patten | SP | 1901 | Westport | 2179 |
| 132 | Billy Jurges | SS | 1931 | Bronx | 2202 |
| 133 | Heathcliff Slocumb | RP | 1991 | Jamaica | 2209 |
| 134 | Danny Richardson | 2B | 1884 | Elmira | 2231 |
| 135 | Bill Duggleby | SP | 1898 | Utica | 2253 |
| 136 | Davy Force | SS | 1871 | New York | 2256 |
| 137 | Jim Deshaies | SP | 1984 | Massena | 2278 |
| 138 | Bob Chipman | RP | 1941 | Brooklyn | 2298 |
| 139 | Joe Hesketh | RP | 1984 | Lackawanna | 2324 |
| 140 | Al Todd | C | 1932 | Troy | 2351 |
| 141 | Bucky Harris | 2B | 1919 | Port Jervis | 2392 |
| 142 | Frank Hankinson | 3B | 1878 | New York | 2394 |
| 143 | Ken Brett | SP | 1967 | Brooklyn | 2405 |
| 144 | Steve Ridzik | RP | 1950 | Yonkers | 2412 |
| 145 | Rube Oldring | CF | 1905 | New York | 2427 |
| 146 | Joe Genewich | SP | 1922 | Elmira | 2429 |
| 147 | Sam Zoldak | RP | 1944 | Brooklyn | 2436 |
| 148 | Bob Bruce | SP | 1959 | New York | 2454 |
| 149 | George Wright | SS | 1871 | New York | 2463 |
| 150 | Bernie Boland | SP | 1915 | Rochester | 2473 |
| 151 | Jason Marquis | SP | 2000 | Manhasset | 2481 |
| 152 | John Cassidy | RF | 1875 | Brooklyn | 2541 |
| 153 | Billy Koch | RP | 1999 | Rockville Centre | 2580 |
| 154 | Bill Lohrman | SP | 1934 | Brooklyn | 2584 |
| 155 | Tom A. Gorman | RP | 1952 | New York | 2644 |
| 156 | Pete Falcone | SP | 1975 | Brooklyn | 2698 |
| 157 | Frank DiPino | RP | 1981 | Syracuse | 2699 |
| 158 | David Palmer | SP | 1978 | Glens Falls | 2700 |
| 159 | Ken Chase | SP | 1936 | Oneonta | 2704 |
| 160 | Marius Russo | SP | 1939 | Brooklyn | 2724 |
| 161 | Irv Noren | CF | 1950 | Jamestown | 2750 |
| 162 | Will White | SP | 1877 | Caton | 2799 |
| 163 | Frankie Pytlak | C | 1932 | Buffalo | 2807 |
| 164 | Doc Scanlan | SP | 1903 | Syracuse | 2844 |
| 165 | Karl Drews | RP | 1946 | Staten Island | 2846 |
| 166 | Joe Lake | SP | 1908 | Brooklyn | 2863 |
| 167 | Frank T. Smith | RP | 1950 | Manor | 2881 |
| 168 | Carl Fischer | SP | 1930 | Medina | 2892 |
| 169 | Frank Isbell | 1B | 1898 | Delevan | 2912 |
| 170 | Lip Pike | CF | 1871 | New York | 2932 |
| 171 | Ross Barnes | 2B | 1871 | Mount Morris | 2944 |
| 172 | Buddy Kerr | SS | 1943 | Astoria | 2945 |
| 173 | Jim Rivera | RF | 1952 | New York | 2947 |
| 174 | Harry Eisenstat | RP | 1935 | Brooklyn | 3011 |
| 175 | Jack Lamabe | RP | 1962 | Farmingdale | 3024 |
| 176 | Neal Heaton | SP | 1982 | South Ozone Park | 3029 |
| 177 | Ed Morris (1862) | SP | 1884 | Brooklyn | 3056 |
| 178 | Ice Box Chamberlain | SP | 1886 | Buffalo | 3068 |
| 179 | Bob Keegan | SP | 1953 | Rochester | 3075 |
| 180 | Mark Guthrie | RP | 1989 | Buffalo | 3090 |
| 181 | Saul Rogovin | SP | 1949 | Brooklyn | 3093 |
| 182 | Dan Casey | SP | 1884 | Binghamton | 3105 |
| 183 | Shawon Dunston | SS | 1985 | Brooklyn | 3144 |
| 184 | Sam Mele | RF | 1947 | Astoria | 3146 |
| 185 | Bill Stafford | SP | 1960 | Catskill | 3148 |
| 186 | Adam Ottavino | RP | 2010 | New York | 3150 |
| 187 | Buddy Hassett | 1B | 1936 | New York | 3201 |
| 188 | Jonah Heim | C | 2020 | Buffalo | 3203 |
| 189 | Dave LaPoint | SP | 1980 | Glens Falls | 3208 |
| 190 | Heinie Wagner | SS | 1902 | New York | 3253 |
| 191 | Hank Majeski | 3B | 1939 | Staten Island | 3302 |
| 192 | Jimmy Dygert | SP | 1905 | Utica | 3311 |
| 193 | Al Fitzmorris | SP | 1969 | Buffalo | 3337 |
| 194 | Dave Lemanczyk | SP | 1973 | Syracuse | 3369 |
| 195 | Shad Barry | RF | 1899 | Newburgh | 3429 |
| 196 | Ed Phelps | C | 1902 | Albany | 3435 |
| 197 | Lee Mazzilli | CF | 1976 | New York | 3443 |
| 198 | Arnie Portocarrero | SP | 1954 | New York | 3470 |
| 199 | Ed Kranepool | 1B | 1962 | New York | 3479 |
| 200 | John Valentin | SS | 1992 | Mineola | 3488 |
| 201 | Ken O'Dea | C | 1935 | Lima | 3556 |
| 202 | Steve Karsay | RP | 1993 | Flushing | 3566 |
| 203 | Jim Mecir | RP | 1995 | Bayside | 3579 |
| 204 | Mike Proly | RP | 1976 | Jamaica | 3592 |
| 205 | Bo Belinsky | SP | 1962 | New York | 3607 |
| 206 | Boileryard Clarke | C | 1893 | New York | 3629 |
| 207 | Mel Hall | LF | 1981 | Lyons | 3667 |
| 208 | Ricky Horton | RP | 1984 | Poughkeepsie | 3674 |
| 209 | Charlie Williams | RP | 1971 | Flushing | 3678 |
| 210 | Bob Aspromonte | 3B | 1956 | Brooklyn | 3712 |
| 211 | Dick Johnston | CF | 1884 | Kingston | 3725 |
| 212 | Kirt Manwaring | C | 1987 | Elmira | 3738 |
| 213 | Steven Matz | SP | 2015 | Stony Brook | 3747 |
| 214 | George Kirby | SP | 2022 | Rye | 3766 |
| 215 | Dave Eggler | CF | 1871 | Brooklyn | 3767 |
| 216 | Rich Aurilia | SS | 1995 | Brooklyn | 3780 |
| 217 | Dave Hollins | 3B | 1990 | Buffalo | 3781 |
| 218 | Buttons Briggs | SP | 1896 | Poughkeepsie | 3793 |
| 219 | Val Picinich | C | 1916 | New York | 3845 |
| 220 | Tim Jordan | 1B | 1901 | New York | 3871 |
| 221 | Danny McDevitt | RP | 1957 | New York | 3883 |
| 222 | Jack Warner | C | 1895 | New York | 3885 |
| 223 | Rick Manning | CF | 1975 | Niagara Falls | 3886 |
| 224 | John Habyan | RP | 1985 | Bay Shore | 3925 |
| 225 | Dave Valle | C | 1984 | Bayside | 3935 |
| 226 | Eddie Murphy | RF | 1912 | Hancock | 3954 |
| 227 | John Flaherty | C | 1992 | New York | 3987 |
| 228 | Tommy Clarke | C | 1909 | New York | 4006 |
| 229 | Paul Gibson | RP | 1988 | Southampton | 4019 |
| 230 | Lady Baldwin | SP | 1884 | Oramel | 4031 |
| 231 | Allen Watson | SP | 1993 | Jamaica | 4034 |
| 232 | Harry Feldman | SP | 1941 | New York | 4042 |
| 233 | Andy Karl | RP | 1943 | Mount Vernon | 4046 |
| 234 | Mike Epstein | 1B | 1966 | Bronx | 4050 |
| 235 | Hank Fischer | RP | 1962 | Yonkers | 4062 |
| 236 | Bill Craver | 2B | 1871 | Troy | 4074 |
| 237 | Jeff Hoffman | RP | 2016 | Latham | 4108 |
| 238 | Mel Queen Jr. | RP | 1964 | Johnson City | 4135 |
| 239 | George G. Bell | SP | 1907 | Greenwood | 4146 |
| 240 | Ronnie Belliard | 2B | 1998 | New York | 4189 |
| 241 | Howie Krist | RP | 1937 | West Henrietta | 4191 |
| 242 | Dude Esterbrook | 3B | 1880 | Staten Island | 4196 |
| 243 | Jack Remsen | CF | 1872 | Brooklyn | 4242 |
| 244 | Babe Young | 1B | 1936 | Astoria | 4257 |
| 245 | Jesse Winker | LF | 2017 | Buffalo | 4281 |
| 246 | Ed Lynch | RP | 1980 | Brooklyn | 4296 |
| 247 | Damion Easley | 2B | 1992 | New York | 4305 |
| 248 | John Cerutti | SP | 1985 | Albany | 4319 |
| 249 | Hank Behrman | RP | 1946 | Brooklyn | 4350 |
| 250 | Bob Trowbridge | RP | 1956 | Hudson | 4361 |
| 251 | George Zettlein | SP | 1871 | Williamsburg | 4380 |
| 252 | Ed Glynn | RP | 1975 | New York | 4393 |
| 253 | David DeJesus | CF | 2003 | Brooklyn | 4429 |
| 254 | Curt Blefary | LF | 1965 | Brooklyn | 4434 |
| 255 | Joe Birmingham | CF | 1906 | Elmira | 4537 |
| 256 | Jack Lynch | SP | 1881 | New York | 4552 |
| 257 | Al Corwin | RP | 1951 | Newburgh | 4606 |
| 258 | Sibby Sisti | 2B | 1939 | Buffalo | 4615 |
| 259 | John Halama | RP | 1998 | Brooklyn | 4616 |
| 260 | Harold Treadwell | SP | 1919 | Huntington | 4662 |
| 261 | Chief Roseman | RF | 1882 | Brooklyn | 4674 |
| 262 | Billy Urbanski | SS | 1931 | Linoleumville | 4685 |
| 263 | Jim Ri. Poole | RP | 1990 | Rochester | 4692 |
| 264 | Terry Larkin | SP | 1876 | Brooklyn | 4694 |
| 265 | Frank Mountain | SP | 1880 | Fort Edward | 4734 |
| 266 | Jim Holdsworth | CF | 1872 | New York | 4775 |
| 267 | Dad Clarke | SP | 1888 | Oswego | 4818 |
| 268 | Dave Orr | 1B | 1883 | New York | 4828 |
| 269 | Joe Ginsberg | C | 1948 | New York | 4836 |
| 270 | Tommy Kahnle | RP | 2014 | Latham | 4846 |
| 271 | Dave Martinez | CF | 1986 | New York | 4848 |
| 272 | John Glenn | LF | 1871 | Rochester | 4931 |
| 273 | Ray Searage | RP | 1981 | Freeport | 4934 |
| 274 | Tim Redding | SP | 2001 | Rochester | 4939 |
| 275 | Tommy Boggs | SP | 1976 | Poughkeepsie | 4942 |
| 276 | Mike Armstrong | RP | 1980 | Glen Cove | 4961 |
| 277 | Fred Lasher | RP | 1963 | Poughkeepsie | 4975 |
| 278 | Walt Weiss | SS | 1987 | Tuxedo | 4988 |
| 279 | Mellie Wolfgang | RP | 1914 | Albany | 5001 |
| 280 | Claude Rossman | 1B | 1904 | Philmont | 5011 |
| 281 | Glenn Spencer | RP | 1928 | Corning | 5030 |
| 282 | Joe Panik | 2B | 2014 | Yonkers | 5034 |
| 283 | Willie Fraser | RP | 1986 | New York | 5048 |
| 284 | Dom Zanni | RP | 1958 | Bronx | 5058 |
| 285 | Al Burch | CF | 1906 | Albany | 5066 |
| 286 | Jeimer Candelario | 3B | 2016 | New York | 5069 |
| 287 | Johnny Enzmann | RP | 1914 | Brooklyn | 5100 |
| 288 | Johnny Mokan | LF | 1921 | Buffalo | 5146 |
| 289 | Xavier Rescigno | RP | 1943 | New York | 5166 |
| 290 | Emerson Dickman | RP | 1936 | Buffalo | 5182 |
| 291 | Nelson Figueroa | RP | 2000 | Brooklyn | 5258 |
| 292 | Jack Cronin | SP | 1895 | West New Brighton | 5264 |
| 293 | John Lannan | SP | 2007 | Long Beach | 5276 |
| 294 | Joe Foy | 3B | 1966 | New York | 5293 |
| 295 | Bill Scherrer | RP | 1982 | Tonawanda | 5303 |
| 296 | Jack Sharrott | SP | 1890 | Staten Island | 5311 |
| 297 | George Myers | C | 1884 | Buffalo | 5390 |
| 298 | Jim Greengrass | LF | 1952 | Addison | 5399 |
| 299 | Julio Cruz | 2B | 1977 | Brooklyn | 5402 |
| 300 | Joe Farrell | 3B | 1882 | Brooklyn | 5408 |
| 301 | Sam Cooper | SP | 1923 | Brooklyn | 5420 |
| 302 | Bobby Wine | SS | 1960 | New York | 5454 |
| 303 | Michael King | RP | 2019 | Rochester | 5472 |
| 304 | Cool Turner | SS | 1921 | Brooklyn | 5497 |
| 305 | Ted Lepcio | 2B | 1952 | Utica | 5636 |
| 306 | Hugh Bedient | SP | 1912 | Gerry | 5637 |
| 307 | Billy Lauder | 3B | 1898 | New York | 5648 |
| 308 | Roy Wilkinson | RP | 1918 | Canandaigua | 5676 |
| 309 | Eric Soderholm | 3B | 1971 | Cortland | 5689 |
| 310 | Larry Bearnarth | RP | 1963 | New York | 5696 |
| 311 | Josiah Gray | SP | 2021 | New Rochelle | 5701 |
| 312 | Fred Treacey | LF | 1871 | Brooklyn | 5710 |
| 313 | Sam Nahem | RP | 1938 | New York | 5768 |
| 314 | Charlie Pabor | LF | 1871 | Brooklyn | 5774 |
| 315 | Rip Coleman | RP | 1955 | Troy | 5794 |
| 316 | Johnny Gee | RP | 1939 | Syracuse | 5809 |
| 317 | Rob Gardner | RP | 1965 | Binghamton | 5814 |
| 318 | Moe Berg | C | 1923 | New York | 5819 |
| 319 | Jerry Casale | SP | 1958 | Brooklyn | 5844 |
| 320 | Fritz Clausen | SP | 1892 | New York | 5912 |
| 321 | C.J. Nitkowski | RP | 1995 | Suffern | 5927 |
| 322 | Rob Bell | SP | 2000 | Newburgh | 5946 |
| 323 | Ira Thomas | C | 1906 | Ballston Spa | 5948 |
| 324 | Hank Gornicki | RP | 1941 | Niagara Falls | 5979 |
| 325 | Irv Waldron | CF | 1901 | Hillside | 6026 |
| 326 | Randy St. Claire | RP | 1984 | Glens Falls | 6035 |
| 327 | Doc Kennedy | C | 1879 | Brooklyn | 6039 |
| 328 | Billy O'Brien | 1B | 1884 | Albany | 6052 |
| 329 | Al Mattern | SP | 1908 | West Rush | 6083 |
| 330 | Cinders O'Brien | SP | 1888 | Troy | 6137 |
| 331 | Frankie Rodriguez | RP | 1995 | Brooklyn | 6151 |
| 332 | Tom Koehler | SP | 2012 | Bronx | 6188 |
| 333 | Tuck Turner | LF | 1893 | West New Brighton | 6199 |
| 334 | Mike Barlow | RP | 1975 | Stamford | 6223 |
| 335 | Red Hoff | RP | 1911 | Ossining | 6228 |
| 336 | Triston McKenzie | SP | 2020 | Brooklyn | 6242 |
| 337 | Steve Roser | RP | 1944 | Rome | 6263 |
| 338 | Bobby Reis | RP | 1931 | Woodside | 6276 |
| 339 | Dave Fleming | SP | 1991 | Jackson Heights | 6281 |
| 340 | Marion Fricano | RP | 1952 | Brant | 6299 |
| 341 | Kevin Kobel | SP | 1973 | Buffalo | 6307 |
| 342 | Al Schacht | RP | 1919 | New York | 6353 |
| 343 | Nat Hicks | C | 1872 | Hempstead | 6388 |
| 344 | Harry McCormick | SP | 1879 | Syracuse | 6404 |
| 345 | Whitey Wilshere | SP | 1934 | Poplar Ridge | 6438 |
| 346 | Mike Regan | SP | 1917 | Phoenix | 6461 |
| 347 | Jim Clinton | RF | 1872 | New York | 6468 |
| 348 | Jumbo Latham | 1B | 1875 | Utica | 6469 |
| 349 | Mike Nagy | SP | 1969 | New York | 6470 |
| 350 | Doc Farrell | SS | 1925 | Johnson City | 6544 |
| 351 | Don DeMola | RP | 1974 | Glen Cove | 6561 |
| 352 | Jim Britton | RP | 1967 | North Tonawanda | 6613 |
| 353 | Jack O'Brien | LF | 1899 | Watervliet | 6622 |
| 354 | Tinti Molina | SP | 1929 | Brooklyn | 6631 |
| 355 | John Johnstone | RP | 1993 | Liverpool | 6641 |
| 356 | Herman Dehlman | 1B | 1872 | Brooklyn | 6644 |
| 357 | John Frascatore | RP | 1994 | Ozone Park | 6684 |
| 358 | Frank Catalanotto | LF | 1997 | Smithtown | 6722 |
| 359 | Mike Mansell | LF | 1879 | Auburn | 6736 |
| 360 | Ian Anderson | SP | 2020 | Rexford | 6744 |
| 361 | Jose de Jesus | SP | 1988 | Brooklyn | 6745 |
| 362 | Mike Griffin | CF | 1887 | Utica | 6756 |
| 363 | Iron Davis | SP | 1912 | Lancaster | 6764 |
| 364 | Eddie Booth | RF | 1872 | Brooklyn | 6783 |
| 365 | Hack Miller | LF | 1916 | New York | 6816 |
| 366 | Ed Murphy | SP | 1898 | Auburn | 6832 |
| 367 | Asa Brainard | SP | 1871 | Albany | 6837 |
| 368 | Bill Short | RP | 1960 | Kingston | 6871 |
| 369 | Elmer Steele | RP | 1907 | Muitzes Kill | 6919 |
| 370 | Stan Rojek | SS | 1942 | North Tonawanda | 6934 |
| 371 | Oscar Walker | 1B | 1875 | Brooklyn | 6949 |
| 372 | Fred Odwell | LF | 1904 | Downsville | 6950 |
| 373 | William Fischer | C | 1913 | New York | 6958 |
| 374 | Al Grabowski | RP | 1929 | Syracuse | 6961 |
| 375 | Frank Fanovich | RP | 1949 | New York | 6990 |
| 376 | Dickey Pearce | SS | 1871 | Brooklyn | 7027 |
| 377 | Jerry Lane | RP | 1953 | Ashland | 7031 |
| 378 | Josh Billings (P) | SP | 1929 | New York | 7034 |
| 379 | Dan Stearns | 1B | 1880 | Buffalo | 7045 |
| 380 | Reggie Grabowski | RP | 1932 | Syracuse | 7050 |
| 381 | Frank Fleet | 2B | 1871 | New York | 7080 |
| 382 | Ed Bagley | SP | 1884 | New York | 7102 |
| 383 | Geoff Geary | RP | 2003 | Buffalo | 7188 |
| 384 | Ed Donnelly | SP | 1911 | Hampton | 7213 |
| 385 | Jumbo Davis | 3B | 1884 | New York | 7258 |
| 386 | Snake Wiltse | SP | 1901 | Bouckville | 7263 |
| 387 | Frank Torre | 1B | 1956 | Brooklyn | 7286 |
| 388 | Roger Bowman | RP | 1949 | Amsterdam | 7289 |
| 389 | Earle Brucker | C | 1937 | Albany | 7304 |
| 390 | Harry L. Taylor | 1B | 1890 | Halsey Valley | 7339 |
| 391 | Karl Spooner | SP | 1954 | Oriskany Falls | 7341 |
| 392 | Harrison Bader | CF | 2017 | Bronxville | 7348 |
| 393 | Rube Kroh | SP | 1906 | Friendship | 7349 |
| 394 | Count Gedney | LF | 1872 | New York | 7351 |
| 395 | Dan Pasqua | LF | 1985 | Yonkers | 7374 |
| 396 | Hal Goldsmith | RP | 1926 | Peconic | 7388 |
| 397 | Frank Kreutzer | RP | 1962 | Buffalo | 7416 |
| 398 | Ben Hayes | RP | 1982 | Niagara Falls | 7455 |
| 399 | Chet Ross | LF | 1939 | Buffalo | 7475 |
| 400 | John Costello | RP | 1988 | Bronx | 7484 |
| 401 | Craig Skok | RP | 1973 | Dobbs Ferry | 7518 |
| 402 | Babe Birrer | RP | 1955 | Buffalo | 7575 |
| 403 | John Coleman | SP | 1883 | Saratoga Springs | 7639 |
| 404 | James Karinchak | RP | 2019 | Newburg | 7642 |
| 405 | Vince Molyneaux | RP | 1917 | Lewiston | 7675 |
| 406 | Mark Lemke | 2B | 1988 | Utica | 7682 |
| 407 | Kevin Siegrist | RP | 2013 | Buffalo | 7723 |
| 408 | Benny Bengough | C | 1923 | Niagara Falls | 7730 |
| 409 | Bob Davis (RP) | RP | 1958 | New York | 7773 |
| 410 | Mike Chartak | RF | 1940 | Brooklyn | 7822 |
| 411 | Phonney Martin | RF | 1872 | New York | 7829 |
| 412 | Bennie Wilson | RF | 1923 | New York | 7835 |
| 413 | Dave Telgheder | SP | 1993 | Middletown | 7841 |
| 414 | Gene Larkin | 1B | 1987 | Flushing | 7842 |
| 415 | Wickey McAvoy | C | 1913 | Rochester | 7845 |
| 416 | Dave Von Ohlen | RP | 1983 | Flushing | 7876 |
| 417 | Al Severinsen | RP | 1969 | Brooklyn | 7881 |
| 418 | Chuck Schilling | 2B | 1961 | Brooklyn | 7895 |
| 419 | John Milligan | RP | 1928 | Schuylerville | 7918 |
| 420 | Arnie Stone | RP | 1923 | North Creek | 7947 |
| 421 | Pat Martin | SP | 1919 | Brooklyn | 7966 |
| 422 | Hank Webb | SP | 1972 | Copiague | 7990 |
| 423 | Bud Anderson | RP | 1982 | Westbury | 8043 |
| 424 | Emil Batch | 3B | 1904 | Brooklyn | 8046 |
| 425 | Tom Sullivan | SP | 1884 | New York | 8050 |
| 426 | Jim Connor | 2B | 1892 | Port Jervis | 8065 |
| 427 | Wally Holborow | RP | 1948 | New York | 8079 |
| 428 | Steve Grilli | RP | 1975 | Brooklyn | 8080 |
| 429 | Bob Cooney | RP | 1931 | Glens Falls | 8084 |
| 430 | Jimmy Wood | 2B | 1871 | Brooklyn | 8088 |
| 431 | Tommy Brown | SS | 1944 | Brooklyn | 8093 |
| 432 | Larry McKeon | SP | 1884 | New York | 8117 |
| 433 | Jackie Hayes (1861) | CF | 1882 | Brooklyn | 8129 |
| 434 | Dasher Troy | 2B | 1881 | New York | 8148 |
| 435 | Paul Cook | C | 1884 | Caledonia | 8175 |
| 436 | Ken Aspromonte | 2B | 1957 | Brooklyn | 8189 |
| 437 | Nick Tropeano | RP | 2014 | West Islip | 8223 |
| 438 | Pete J. O'Brien | 2B | 1901 | Binghamton | 8258 |
| 439 | Joe Kiefer | RP | 1920 | West Leyden | 8265 |
| 440 | Roger Weaver | RP | 1980 | Amsterdam | 8295 |
| 441 | Ray Gordinier | RP | 1921 | Rochester | 8316 |
| 442 | Justin Topa | RP | 2020 | Binghamton | 8351 |
| 443 | George Mohart | RP | 1920 | Buffalo | 8361 |
| 444 | Dick Buckley | C | 1888 | Troy | 8365 |
| 445 | Jay Kirke | LF | 1910 | Fleischmanns | 8374 |
| 446 | Dave Gerard | RP | 1962 | New York | 8400 |
| 447 | Pat Simmons | RP | 1928 | Watervliet | 8451 |
| 448 | John Pacella | RP | 1977 | Brooklyn | 8469 |
| 449 | Gene Krapp | SP | 1911 | Rochester | 8470 |
| 450 | Mike Aviles | SS | 2008 | New York | 8475 |
| 451 | Will Cunnane | RP | 1997 | Suffern | 8493 |
| 452 | Floyd Chiffer | RP | 1982 | Glen Cove | 8497 |
| 453 | Frank Eufemia | RP | 1985 | Bronx | 8501 |
| 454 | Frank Bork | RP | 1964 | Buffalo | 8502 |
| 455 | Walter Brown | RP | 1947 | Jamestown | 8504 |
| 456 | Mike Jones | RP | 1980 | Rochester | 8537 |
| 457 | Ensign Cottrell | RP | 1911 | Hoosick Falls | 8541 |
| 458 | Sal Campisi | RP | 1969 | Brooklyn | 8557 |
| 459 | Joe Gleason | RP | 1920 | Phelps | 8565 |
| 460 | Neal Finn | 2B | 1930 | Brooklyn | 8593 |
| 461 | Ed McDonald | 3B | 1911 | Albany | 8608 |
| 462 | Charlie Girard | RP | 1910 | Brooklyn | 8622 |
| 463 | Mickey Hughes | SP | 1888 | New York | 8649 |
| 464 | Ed Connolly | SP | 1964 | Brooklyn | 8677 |
| 465 | Jim Britt | SP | 1872 | Tonawanda | 8679 |
| 466 | Jay Faatz | 1B | 1884 | Weedsport | 8709 |
| 467 | Specs Toporcer | SS | 1921 | New York | 8747 |
| 468 | Zip Collins | CF | 1914 | Brooklyn | 8771 |
| 469 | Gene Lansing | RP | 1922 | Albany | 8799 |
| 470 | Peter Munro | RP | 1999 | Flushing | 8823 |
| 471 | Billy Zitzmann | LF | 1919 | Long Island City | 8827 |
| 472 | Steve Bailey | RP | 1967 | Bronx | 8842 |
| 473 | Otto Rettig | SP | 1922 | New York | 8853 |
| 474 | Harry Eccles | RP | 1915 | Kennedy | 8857 |
| 475 | Chick Robitaille | SP | 1904 | Whitehall | 8905 |
| 476 | Hack Eibel | RP | 1912 | Brooklyn | 8921 |
| 477 | Bill Boyd | 3B | 1872 | New York | 8929 |
| 478 | Jack Phillips | 1B | 1947 | Clarence | 8930 |
| 479 | Al Ferrara | LF | 1963 | Brooklyn | 8934 |
| 480 | Richie Scheinblum | RF | 1965 | New York | 8943 |
| 481 | Ed Madjeski | C | 1932 | Far Rockaway | 8949 |
| 482 | Henry Kessler | SS | 1873 | Brooklyn | 8956 |
| 483 | Alex Gaston | C | 1920 | New York | 8957 |
| 484 | Ralph Mauriello | SP | 1958 | Brooklyn | 8966 |
| 485 | Les Howe | RP | 1923 | Brooklyn | 8977 |
| 486 | Charlie Boardman | RP | 1913 | Seneca Falls | 8978 |
| 487 | Bob Giallombardo | SP | 1958 | Brooklyn | 9018 |
| 488 | Tom Veryzer | SS | 1973 | Port Jefferson | 9047 |
| 489 | Charlie Reipschlager | C | 1883 | New York | 9054 |
| 490 | Howard Earl | RF | 1890 | Palmyra | 9056 |
| 491 | Josh Bard | C | 2002 | Ithaca | 9061 |
| 492 | Art Mills | RP | 1927 | Utica | 9079 |
| 493 | Don Gordon | RP | 1986 | New York | 9085 |
| 494 | Derrick May | LF | 1990 | Rochester | 9089 |
| 495 | Norm Lehr | RP | 1926 | Rochester | 9119 |
| 496 | Bud Culloton | RP | 1925 | Kingston | 9120 |
| 497 | Bill Connors | RP | 1966 | Schenectady | 9137 |
| 498 | Biff Schlitzer | SP | 1908 | Rochester | 9159 |
| 499 | Fred Jacklitsch | C | 1900 | Brooklyn | 9195 |
| 500 | Moose Grimshaw | 1B | 1905 | St. Johnsville | 9206 |
| 501 | Emmet Sheehan | SP | 2023 | New York | 9211 |
| 502 | Danny Gardella | LF | 1944 | New York | 9261 |
| 503 | Clint Blume | RP | 1922 | Brooklyn | 9278 |
| 504 | Leon Carlson | RP | 1920 | Jamestown | 9280 |
| 505 | Tom Barlow | C | 1872 | Unknown | 9285 |
| 506 | Rinty Monahan | RP | 1953 | Brooklyn | 9308 |
| 507 | Mike Meola | RP | 1933 | New York | 9316 |
| 508 | Gil Rondon | RP | 1976 | Bronx | 9354 |
| 509 | Hal Schacker | RP | 1945 | Brooklyn | 9357 |
| 510 | Bill Kalfass | RP | 1937 | New York | 9359 |
| 511 | Mike Kircher | RP | 1919 | Rochester | 9367 |
| 512 | Pat Murray | RP | 1919 | Scottsville | 9368 |
| 513 | Frank Carpin | RP | 1965 | Brooklyn | 9412 |
| 514 | Steve Rosenberg | RP | 1988 | Brooklyn | 9449 |
| 515 | Walter Ancker | RP | 1915 | New York | 9488 |
| 516 | Bill Daley | SP | 1889 | Poughkeepsie | 9503 |
| 517 | Del Mason | SP | 1904 | Newfane | 9505 |
| 518 | Tim Adleman | SP | 2016 | Staten Island | 9516 |
| 519 | Bill Pierro | RP | 1950 | Brooklyn | 9520 |
| 520 | Walter Signer | RP | 1943 | New York | 9521 |
| 521 | Ren Deagle | SP | 1883 | New York | 9533 |
| 522 | Jack Neagle | SP | 1879 | Syracuse | 9534 |
| 523 | Al Weis | 2B | 1962 | Franklin Square | 9590 |
| 524 | Lee Griffeth | RP | 1946 | Carmel | 9599 |
| 525 | Jimmie Keenan | RP | 1920 | Avon | 9605 |
| 526 | Harry Taylor (1866) | 1B | 1890 | Halsey Valley | 9610 |
| 527 | Ed Pinkham | 3B | 1871 | Brooklyn | 9621 |
| 528 | Lynn Lovenguth | RP | 1955 | Camden | 9644 |
| 529 | Lee Howard | RP | 1946 | Staten Island | 9648 |
| 530 | Jimmy Pattison | RP | 1929 | Bronx | 9656 |
| 531 | Charlie Malay | 2B | 1933 | Brooklyn | 9715 |
| 532 | Steve King | LF | 1871 | Lansingburgh | 9725 |
| 533 | Mario Picone | RP | 1947 | Brooklyn | 9756 |
| 534 | Jimmie Reese | 2B | 1930 | New York | 9768 |
| 535 | Fred Lewis (1858) | CF | 1881 | Buffalo | 9775 |
| 536 | Harry Riconda | 3B | 1923 | New York | 9785 |
| 537 | Angelo LiPetri | RP | 1956 | Brooklyn | 9793 |
| 538 | Hiker Moran | RP | 1938 | Rochester | 9798 |
| 539 | Will Calihan | SP | 1890 | Oswego | 9805 |
| 540 | Warren White | 3B | 1871 | Milton | 9825 |
| 541 | Pop Schriver | C | 1886 | Brooklyn | 9834 |
| 542 | Mort Flohr | RP | 1934 | Canisteo | 9847 |
| 543 | Jake Pitler | 2B | 1917 | New York | 9851 |
| 544 | Herm Doscher | 3B | 1872 | New York | 9875 |
| 545 | Alan Storke | 1B | 1906 | Auburn | 9882 |
| 546 | Jason Foley | RP | 2021 | Manhasset | 9888 |
| 547 | Bots Nekola | RP | 1929 | New York | 9901 |
| 548 | Al Kellett | RP | 1923 | New York | 9904 |
| 549 | Tom Carroll | SP | 1974 | Oriskany | 9911 |
| 550 | George Meakim | SP | 1890 | Brooklyn | 9925 |
| 551 | Colin Moran | DH | 2016 | Port Chester | 9927 |
| 552 | Tony Balsamo | RP | 1962 | Brooklyn | 9941 |
| 553 | Chink Zachary | SP | 1944 | Brooklyn | 9948 |
| 554 | Hank Simon | LF | 1887 | Hawkinsville | 9963 |
| 555 | John Schappert | SP | 1882 | Brooklyn | 9965 |
| 556 | Harry Raymond | 3B | 1888 | Sauquoit | 9972 |
| 557 | Chris Stynes | 3B | 1995 | Queens | 9987 |
| 558 | Justin Dunn | SP | 2019 | Freeport | 9990 |
| 559 | Ted Scheffler | RF | 1888 | New York | 10009 |
| 560 | Bert Dorr | SP | 1882 | New York | 10010 |
| 561 | Rich N. Thompson | RP | 1985 | New York | 10012 |
| 562 | Fred Waterman | 3B | 1871 | New York | 10024 |
| 563 | Todd Williams | RP | 1995 | Syracuse | 10035 |
| 564 | Bill Oster | RP | 1954 | New York | 10040 |
| 565 | Bill Fagan | SP | 1887 | Troy | 10065 |
| 566 | Mike Bruhert | SP | 1978 | Jamaica | 10080 |
| 567 | Jack Doscher | SP | 1903 | Troy | 10098 |
| 568 | Myron Allen | LF | 1883 | Kingston | 10102 |
| 569 | Lou Limmer | 1B | 1951 | New York | 10107 |
| 570 | Frank Seminara | SP | 1992 | Brooklyn | 10118 |
| 571 | Clay Van Alstyne | RP | 1927 | Stuyvesant | 10137 |
| 572 | Fred Payne | C | 1906 | Camden | 10162 |
| 573 | Bill Schenck | 3B | 1882 | Brooklyn | 10167 |
| 574 | Tommy Beals | CF | 1871 | New York | 10169 |
| 575 | Jap Barbeau | 3B | 1905 | New York | 10174 |
| 576 | Henry Cotto | CF | 1984 | New York | 10209 |
| 577 | Jim Prendergast | RP | 1948 | Brooklyn | 10237 |
| 578 | Scott Leius | 3B | 1990 | Yonkers | 10261 |
| 579 | Jim Cosman | SP | 1966 | Brockport | 10276 |
| 580 | Charlie Hodes | C | 1871 | New York | 10295 |
| 581 | Joe Gallagher | LF | 1939 | Buffalo | 10326 |
| 582 | Monk Sherlock | 1B | 1930 | Buffalo | 10335 |
| 583 | Bugs Reisigl | SP | 1911 | Brooklyn | 10339 |
| 584 | James McDermott | SP | 1871 | Brooklyn | 10346 |
| 585 | Bill Traffley | C | 1878 | Staten Island | 10349 |
| 586 | Bill Cunningham (2B) | 2B | 1910 | Schenectady | 10381 |
| 587 | Jimmy Esmond | SS | 1911 | Albany | 10388 |
| 588 | Dave Birdsall | RF | 1871 | New York | 10396 |
| 589 | Bub McAtee | 1B | 1871 | Troy | 10398 |
| 590 | Bill Chappelle | RP | 1908 | Waterloo | 10413 |
| 591 | Clipper Flynn | 1B | 1871 | Lansingburgh | 10480 |
| 592 | Gary Christenson | RP | 1979 | Mineola | 10481 |
| 593 | John Valentine | SP | 1883 | Brooklyn | 10531 |
| 594 | Gerry Hannahs | SP | 1976 | Binghamton | 10537 |
| 595 | Kevin McCarthy | RP | 2016 | Rockville Centre | 10544 |
| 596 | Mike Lehane | 1B | 1890 | New York | 10550 |
| 597 | Don Cooper | RP | 1981 | New York | 10564 |
| 598 | Tony Graffanino | 2B | 1996 | Amityville | 10593 |
| 599 | Logan O'Hoppe | C | 2022 | West Islip | 10629 |
| 600 | Ed Dugan | SP | 1884 | Brooklyn | 10661 |
| 601 | Tom Evers | 2B | 1882 | Troy | 10662 |
| 602 | Joe Pignatano | C | 1957 | Brooklyn | 10670 |
| 603 | Hugh O'Neil | SP | 1875 | Brooklyn | 10708 |
| 604 | Frank Riccelli | RP | 1976 | Syracuse | 10718 |
| 605 | George Townsend | C | 1887 | Hartsdale | 10720 |
| 606 | Eddie Basinski | SS | 1944 | Buffalo | 10725 |
| 607 | Tom Dolan | C | 1879 | New York | 10729 |
| 608 | Jack Chapman | RF | 1874 | Brooklyn | 10749 |
| 609 | Phil Powers | C | 1878 | New York | 10772 |
| 610 | Wayne Rosenthal | RP | 1991 | Brooklyn | 10782 |
| 611 | Conrad Cardinal | RP | 1963 | Brooklyn | 10784 |
| 612 | Jonah Goldman | SS | 1928 | New York | 10787 |
| 613 | Pete Hamm | SP | 1970 | Buffalo | 10812 |
| 614 | Scott Cassidy | RP | 2002 | Syracuse | 10817 |
| 615 | Anthony Varvaro | RP | 2010 | Staten Island | 10821 |
| 616 | Hy Cohen | RP | 1955 | Brooklyn | 10831 |
| 617 | Frank Diven | SP | 1883 | Brooklyn | 10840 |
| 618 | Luis Garcia (2000) | 2B | 2020 | New York | 10852 |
| 619 | Greg Keagle | SP | 1996 | Corning | 10891 |
| 620 | Bert Lewis | RP | 1924 | Tonawanda | 10916 |
| 621 | John Hamill | SP | 1884 | New York | 10919 |
| 622 | Terry Crowley | RF | 1969 | Staten Island | 10924 |
| 623 | John Cangelosi | CF | 1985 | Brooklyn | 10936 |
| 624 | Fraley Rogers | RF | 1872 | Brooklyn | 10960 |
| 625 | Joe Simmons | LF | 1871 | New York | 10968 |
| 626 | Larry Yellen | RP | 1963 | Brooklyn | 10988 |
| 627 | Cliff Brantley | RP | 1991 | Staten Island | 11002 |
| 628 | Tom Mansell | CF | 1879 | Auburn | 11061 |
| 629 | Brendan Harris | SS | 2004 | Queensbury | 11128 |
| 630 | Sandy Griffin | CF | 1884 | Fayetteville | 11131 |
| 631 | Joe Ausanio | RP | 1994 | Kingston | 11148 |
| 632 | Buck Becannon | SP | 1884 | New York | 11201 |
| 633 | Bob Murphy | SP | 1890 | Dutchess County | 11241 |
| 634 | Bill Duzen | SP | 1890 | Buffalo | 11323 |
| 635 | George Seward | RF | 1875 | New York | 11327 |
| 636 | Tom Forster | 2B | 1882 | New York | 11343 |
| 637 | Billy Barnie | C | 1874 | New York | 11376 |
| 638 | Boots Day | CF | 1969 | Ilion | 11379 |
| 639 | Jim Norris | RF | 1977 | Brooklyn | 11403 |
| 640 | Rooney Sweeney | C | 1883 | New York | 11406 |
| 641 | Mike Caruso | SS | 1998 | Queens | 11417 |
| 642 | Jim Powers | SP | 1890 | New York | 11448 |
| 643 | Charlie Mills | C | 1871 | Brooklyn | 11451 |
| 644 | Gracie Pierce | 2B | 1882 | New York | 11496 |
| 645 | Bill Morgan | LF | 1882 | Brooklyn | 11499 |
| 646 | Hack Simmons | 2B | 1910 | Brooklyn | 11505 |
| 647 | Art Schult | 1B | 1953 | Brooklyn | 11532 |
| 648 | Mike Ferraro | 3B | 1966 | Kingston | 11574 |
| 649 | Gus Williams (1870) | SP | 1890 | New York | 11581 |
| 650 | Frank Beck | SP | 1884 | Poughkeepsie | 11620 |
| 651 | John Mansell | CF | 1882 | Auburn | 11621 |
| 652 | Harvey Blauvelt | SP | 1890 | New York | 11668 |
| 653 | Dennis Casey | CF | 1884 | Binghamton | 11684 |
| 654 | Jake Knodell | C | 1874 | Brooklyn | 11692 |
| 655 | Al Heist | CF | 1960 | Brooklyn | 11704 |
| 656 | Bob Fallon | RP | 1984 | Bronx | 11728 |
| 657 | Frank Fernandez | C | 1967 | Staten Island | 11751 |
| 658 | Sal Romano | SP | 2017 | Syosset | 11757 |
| 659 | Ross Gload | 1B | 2000 | Brooklyn | 11806 |
| 660 | Herman Pitz | C | 1890 | Brooklyn | 11822 |
| 661 | Tom Patterson | CF | 1871 | New York | 11824 |
| 662 | Miguel Jimenez | SP | 1993 | New York | 11882 |
| 663 | Joe Sargent | 2B | 1921 | Rochester | 11906 |
| 664 | Jim Snyder | SS | 1872 | Brooklyn | 11947 |
| 665 | Mickey Brantley | LF | 1986 | Catskill | 11973 |
| 666 | Rafael Novoa | RP | 1990 | New York | 11991 |
| 667 | John McGlone | 3B | 1886 | Brooklyn | 11995 |
| 668 | John McKelvey | RF | 1875 | Rochester | 12030 |
| 669 | Frank McCarton | CF | 1872 | New York | 12031 |
| 670 | Marshall King | CF | 1871 | Lansingburgh | 12032 |
| 671 | Heinie Scheer | 2B | 1922 | New York | 12033 |
| 672 | Tom Cosgrove | RP | 2023 | Staten Island | 12050 |
| 673 | Bill Hughes | 1B | 1884 | Brooklyn | 12054 |
| 674 | Ralph Ham | LF | 1871 | Troy | 12070 |
| 675 | Dennis Sarfate | RP | 2006 | Queens | 12095 |
| 676 | Mike Goodfellow | RF | 1887 | Port Jervis | 12112 |
| 677 | Pat McGee | CF | 1874 | New York | 12119 |
| 678 | Ebba St. Claire | C | 1951 | Whitehall | 12122 |
| 679 | Gene Kimball | 2B | 1871 | Rochester | 12146 |
| 680 | Jim Dougherty | RP | 1995 | Brentwood | 12167 |
| 681 | Jim Farr | RP | 1982 | Waverly | 12181 |
| 682 | Rudy Arroyo | RP | 1971 | New York | 12184 |
| 683 | Joe Kelly (1900) | LF | 1926 | New York | 12186 |
| 684 | Alex Arias | SS | 1992 | New York | 12202 |
| 685 | Tim Adleman | SP | 2016 | Staten Island | 12223 |
| 686 | Glen Cook | SP | 1985 | Buffalo | 12228 |
| 687 | Joe Wagner | 2B | 1915 | New York | 12232 |
| 688 | Bill Dreesen | 3B | 1931 | New York | 12281 |
| 689 | Henry Austin | RF | 1873 | Unknown | 12285 |
| 690 | Dave McKeough | C | 1890 | Utica | 12287 |
| 691 | George Hunter | SP | 1909 | Buffalo | 12299 |
| 692 | Danny Barnes | RP | 2016 | Manhasset | 12316 |
| 693 | Lave Winham | SP | 1902 | Brooklyn | 12333 |
| 694 | Hughie Hearne | C | 1901 | Troy | 12334 |
| 695 | Spider Clark | RF | 1889 | Brooklyn | 12335 |
| 696 | Frank Menechino | 2B | 1999 | Staten Island | 12346 |
| 697 | Charlie Smith (1840) | 3B | 1871 | Brooklyn | 12377 |
| 698 | Frank Drews | 2B | 1944 | Buffalo | 12393 |
| 699 | Harry Berthrong | LF | 1871 | Mumford | 12419 |
| 700 | Ike Van Zandt | RF | 1901 | Brooklyn | 12421 |
| 701 | Pat Callaghan | 3B | 1884 | New York | 12469 |
| 702 | Bill Kelly | RF | 1871 | New York | 12502 |
| 703 | Ben Brown | SP | 2024 | East Setauket | 12524 |
| 704 | Charlie Engle | SS | 1925 | New York | 12531 |
| 705 | John Dailey | SS | 1875 | Brooklyn | 12539 |
| 706 | Jack McDonald | RF | 1872 | Brooklyn | 12541 |
| 707 | Sal Yvars | C | 1947 | New York | 12544 |
| 708 | Shawn Dubin | RP | 2023 | Allegany | 12565 |
| 709 | Billy DeMars | SS | 1948 | Brooklyn | 12571 |
| 710 | Bobby Schang | C | 1914 | Wales Center | 12576 |
| 711 | Sandy McDougal | SP | 1895 | Buffalo | 12580 |
| 712 | Chuck Connors | 1B | 1949 | Brooklyn | 12633 |
| 713 | Andy Allison | 1B | 1872 | New York | 12641 |
| 714 | Brian Sweeney | RP | 2003 | Yonkers | 12647 |
| 715 | Bob Chlupsa | RP | 1970 | New York | 12670 |
| 716 | Ned Bligh | C | 1886 | Brooklyn | 12680 |
| 717 | Steve Geltz | RP | 2012 | Newfane | 12687 |
| 718 | Rich Scheid | RP | 1992 | Staten Island | 12701 |
| 719 | Rip Vowinkel | SP | 1905 | Oswego | 12710 |
| 720 | Scrappy Carroll | RF | 1884 | Buffalo | 12714 |
| 721 | Elmer White | RF | 1871 | Caton | 12716 |
| 722 | Norm Sherry | C | 1959 | New York | 12739 |
| 723 | Al Cuccinello | 2B | 1935 | Long Island City | 12752 |
| 724 | Elmer Zacher | CF | 1910 | Buffalo | 12757 |
| 725 | Frank Bowes | C | 1890 | Bath | 12762 |
| 726 | Jocko Halligan | RF | 1890 | Avon | 12763 |
| 727 | Bill Lennon | C | 1871 | Brooklyn | 12765 |
| 728 | Ben Egan | C | 1908 | Augusta | 12782 |
| 729 | Keefe Cato | RP | 1983 | Yonkers | 12799 |
| 730 | Bill Sommers | 3B | 1950 | Brooklyn | 12834 |
| 731 | Lou Bruce | LF | 1904 | St. Regis | 12844 |
| 732 | Frank Murphy | LF | 1901 | North Tarrytown | 12888 |
| 733 | Tom O'Rourke | C | 1887 | New York | 12890 |
| 734 | Sam Wright | SS | 1875 | New York | 12891 |
| 735 | Jack Coffey | SS | 1909 | New York | 12897 |
| 736 | Hack Schumann | SP | 1906 | Buffalo | 12921 |
| 737 | Keith Osik | C | 1996 | Port Jefferson | 12932 |
| 738 | Archi Cianfrocco | 1B | 1992 | Rome | 12936 |
| 739 | Dutch Dotterer | C | 1957 | Syracuse | 12959 |
| 740 | Huck Geary | SS | 1942 | Buffalo | 12960 |
| 741 | Bill Clancy | 1B | 1905 | Redfield | 12965 |
| 742 | Herb Jackson | SP | 1905 | Elmira | 12966 |
| 743 | Harry Felix | SP | 1901 | Brooklyn | 12968 |
| 744 | Jonathan Hurst | RP | 1992 | New York | 12986 |
| 745 | Don Taussig | LF | 1958 | New York | 13004 |
| 746 | Anthony Kay | SP | 2019 | Stony Brook | 13021 |
| 747 | Craig Hansen | RP | 2005 | Glen Cove | 13030 |
| 748 | Pete O'Brien (1877) | 2B | 1901 | Binghamton | 13051 |
| 749 | Billy Milligan | RP | 1901 | Buffalo | 13057 |
| 750 | Bill Schuster | SS | 1937 | Buffalo | 13109 |
| 751 | Jim Fairbank | RP | 1903 | Deansboro | 13127 |
| 752 | Mike Fiore | 1B | 1968 | Brooklyn | 13131 |
| 753 | Bill Kellogg | 1B | 1914 | Albany | 13147 |
| 754 | Willie Mills | SP | 1901 | Schenevus | 13155 |
| 755 | Fatty Briody | C | 1880 | Lansingburgh | 13159 |
| 756 | Brendan White | RP | 2023 | White Plains | 13175 |
| 757 | She Donahue | SS | 1904 | Oswego | 13230 |
| 758 | Bock Baker | SP | 1901 | Troy | 13232 |
| 759 | Tom Murphy (1991) | C | 2015 | West Monroe | 13247 |
| 760 | Heinie Beckendorf | C | 1909 | New York | 13265 |
| 761 | John Farrow | C | 1873 | Verplanck | 13282 |
| 762 | Matt Daley | RP | 2009 | Flushing | 13324 |
| 763 | Charlie See | CF | 1919 | Pleasantville | 13338 |
| 764 | Frank Barberich | SP | 1907 | New Town | 13340 |
| 765 | Leo Smith | SS | 1890 | Brooklyn | 13343 |
| 766 | Tom O'Hara | LF | 1906 | Waverly | 13396 |
| 767 | Tony Tarasco | RF | 1993 | New York | 13583 |
| 768 | John Pawlowski | RP | 1987 | Johnson City | 13588 |
| 769 | Greg Weissert | RP | 2022 | Bay Shore | 13612 |
| 770 | Jack Gilbert | LF | 1898 | Rhinecliff | 13636 |
| 771 | Lou Hardie | C | 1884 | New York | 13638 |
| 772 | Sean Nolin | SP | 2013 | Seaford | 13642 |
| 773 | Patrick Larkins | 3B | 1884 | Unknown | 13685 |
| 774 | Aleck Smith | C | 1897 | New York | 13723 |
| 775 | Duke Carmel | CF | 1959 | New York | 13744 |
| 776 | Frank Scanlan | RP | 1909 | Syracuse | 13749 |
| 777 | Bill Deegan | SP | 1901 | Bronx | 13795 |
| 778 | Bill Drescher | C | 1946 | Congers | 13829 |
| 779 | George Daly | SP | 1909 | Buffalo | 13831 |
| 780 | Matt Festa | RP | 2018 | Staten Island | 13842 |
| 781 | Peter Strzelecki | RP | 2022 | Queens | 13873 |
| 782 | Bill McCorry | SP | 1909 | Saranac Lake | 13893 |
| 783 | Cy Ferry | SP | 1904 | Hudson | 13900 |
| 784 | Chris Jones | RF | 1991 | Utica | 13950 |
| 785 | Joel Bennett | RP | 1998 | Binghamton | 13970 |
| 786 | Joe Rullo | 2B | 1943 | New York | 13975 |
| 787 | Stan Jefferson | CF | 1986 | New York | 13989 |
| 788 | Pedro Payano | SP | 2019 | New York | 14006 |
| 789 | Fred Siefke | 3B | 1890 | New York | 14046 |
| 790 | Ernie Clement | 2B | 2021 | Rochester | 14051 |
| 791 | Bill Lauterborn | 2B | 1904 | Hornell | 14071 |
| 792 | Bob Brower | CF | 1986 | Jamaica | 14192 |
| 793 | Bobby Vaughn | 2B | 1909 | Stamford | 14207 |
| 794 | Joe Palumbo | SP | 2019 | Holbrook | 14250 |
| 795 | Tim Hamulack | RP | 2005 | Ithaca | 14253 |
| 796 | Danny Mendick | SS | 2019 | Rochester | 14311 |
| 797 | Tom Doran | C | 1904 | Westchester County | 14373 |
| 798 | Brian Gordon | RP | 2008 | West Point | 14398 |
| 799 | Frank Cimorelli | RP | 1994 | Poughkeepsie | 14473 |
| 800 | Phil Mankowski | 3B | 1976 | Buffalo | 14480 |
| 801 | Jason Vosler | 3B | 2021 | West Nyack | 14491 |
| 802 | Dee Brown | LF | 1998 | Bronx | 14539 |
| 803 | Kyle McGowin | RP | 2018 | Southampton | 14544 |
| 804 | Rudy Meoli | SS | 1971 | Troy | 14638 |
| 805 | Tug Wilson | RF | 1884 | Brooklyn | 14672 |
| 806 | Chris O'Grady | RP | 2017 | Congers | 14692 |
| 807 | John Morris (OF) | RF | 1986 | North Bellmore | 14771 |
| 808 | Sal Butera | C | 1980 | Richmond Hill | 14774 |
| 809 | Charlie Jones (1861) | 2B | 1884 | New York | 14847 |
| 810 | Xavier Edwards | SS | 2023 | Mineola | 14876 |
| 811 | Frank Tepedino | 1B | 1967 | Brooklyn | 14896 |
| 812 | Jason Garcia | RP | 2015 | Bronx | 14935 |
| 813 | Richie Palacios | 2B | 2022 | Brooklyn | 14944 |
| 814 | Alex Diaz | CF | 1992 | Brooklyn | 14962 |
| 815 | Eric Junge | RP | 2002 | Manhasset | 14975 |
| 816 | Johnny Lavin | CF | 1884 | Troy | 14977 |
| 817 | Caden Dana | SP | 2024 | Warwick | 14991 |
| 818 | Cole Kimball | RP | 2011 | Brooklyn | 15038 |
| 819 | John Tilley | LF | 1882 | New York | 15041 |
| 820 | Lawrence Farley | LF | 1884 | Seneca Falls | 15064 |
| 821 | Jeff Pierce | RP | 1995 | Poughkeepsie | 15078 |
| 822 | Scott Blewett | RP | 2020 | Syracuse | 15097 |
| 823 | Joe La Sorsa | RP | 2023 | Mount Kisco | 15104 |
| 824 | Tug Arundel | C | 1882 | Auburn | 15123 |
| 825 | Marc Kroon | RP | 1995 | Bronx | 15138 |
| 826 | Tim Locastro | LF | 2017 | Auburn | 15159 |
| 827 | Pidge Browne | 1B | 1962 | Peekskill | 15228 |
| 828 | Kevin Polcovich | SS | 1997 | Auburn | 15254 |
| 829 | Skip Jutze | C | 1972 | Bayside | 15261 |
| 830 | Frank Brooks | RP | 2004 | Brooklyn | 15265 |
| 831 | Jaime Schultz | RP | 2018 | Albany | 15323 |
| 832 | Sal Recca | C | 1940 | Brooklyn | 15364 |
| 833 | Steve Falteisek | RP | 1997 | Mineola | 15434 |
| 834 | Reiss Knehr | RP | 2021 | Manhasset | 15499 |
| 835 | James Jones | CF | 2014 | Brooklyn | 15506 |
| 836 | Jim Maler | 1B | 1981 | New York | 15510 |
| 837 | Henry Davis | RF | 2023 | Bedford | 15518 |
| 838 | Josh Walker | RP | 2023 | Otisville | 15520 |
| 839 | Sammy Peralta | RP | 2023 | Queens | 15523 |
| 840 | Kevin Smith | 3B | 2021 | East Greenbush | 15538 |
| 841 | Zack Short | SS | 2021 | Kingston | 15547 |
| 842 | Andrew Velazquez | SS | 2018 | Bronx | 15562 |
| 843 | James Norwood | RP | 2018 | New York | 15567 |
| 844 | T.J. Rivera | 2B | 2016 | Bronx | 15590 |
| 845 | Jerry Sands | LF | 2011 | Middletown | 15616 |
| 846 | Mike Baxter | RF | 2010 | Queens | 15624 |
| 847 | John Rodriguez | LF | 2005 | New York | 15642 |
| 848 | Jeff Schaefer | SS | 1994 | Patchogue | 15677 |
| 849 | Scott Coolbaugh | 3B | 1989 | Binghamton | 15694 |
| 850 | Paul Runge | 3B | 1981 | Kingston | 15718 |
| 851 | Tom Donohue | C | 1979 | Mineola | 15719 |
| 852 | Brian Slocum | RP | 2006 | New Rochelle | 15742 |
| 853 | Joshua Palacios | RF | 2021 | Brooklyn | 15864 |
| 854 | Justyn-Henry Malloy | DH | 2024 | New York | 15909 |
| 855 | Zach Remillard | 2B | 2023 | Cohoes | 15960 |
| 856 | Matt Gage | RP | 2022 | Johnstown | 15984 |
| 857 | Travis Demeritte | RF | 2019 | New York | 16064 |
| 858 | Zack Granite | CF | 2017 | Staten Island | 16118 |
| 859 | Patrick Kivlehan | RF | 2016 | Nyack | 16137 |
| 860 | Shawn Morimando | RP | 2016 | Canandaigua | 16138 |
| 861 | Danny Burawa | RP | 2015 | Riverhead | 16150 |
| 862 | C.J. Riefenhauser | RP | 2014 | Yonkers | 16175 |
| 863 | Andy Parrino | SS | 2011 | Brockport | 16236 |
| 864 | Darin Mastroianni | RF | 2011 | Mount Kisco | 16242 |
| 865 | Dave Sappelt | LF | 2011 | Buffalo | 16243 |
| 866 | Randy Ruiz | DH | 2008 | Bronx | 16299 |
| 867 | Tim Hummel | 3B | 2003 | Goshen | 16356 |
| 868 | Julius Matos | 2B | 2002 | New York | 16366 |
| 869 | Luis Lopez | 3B | 2001 | Brooklyn | 16376 |
| 870 | Clay Bellinger | CF | 1999 | Oneonta | 16389 |
| 871 | Shane Monahan | LF | 1998 | Syosset | 16406 |
| 872 | Desi Wilson | 1B | 1996 | Glen Cove | 16416 |
| 873 | Izzy Molina | C | 1996 | New York | 16418 |
| 874 | Dan Peltier | RF | 1992 | Clifton Park | 16449 |
| 875 | Gary Scott | 3B | 1991 | New Rochelle | 16456 |
| 876 | Kevin Baez | SS | 1990 | Brooklyn | 16467 |
| 877 | Matt Winters | RF | 1989 | Buffalo | 16474 |
| 878 | Benny Distefano | 1B | 1984 | Brooklyn | 16493 |
| 879 | Willie Lozado | 3B | 1984 | New York | 16501 |
| 880 | Dell Alston | RF | 1977 | Valhalla | 16548 |
| 881 | Fred Cambria | SS | 1970 | Cambria Heights | 16579 |
[Home] [Updates] [Sports] [Upcoming/Recent Events] [Polls] [Contact Us] [Links] [Our Facebook Page] [Our Twitter Page]